Advertisement

China locked down millions in coronavirus-hit Hubei. Has it done more harm than good?

  • Residents are struggling to get much-needed treatment and supplies in Wuhan and other closed-off cities, and the death toll is rising
  • Independent economist Hu Xingdou says it’s time to lift the restrictions and ‘stop this human tragedy that is happening’

Reading Time:7 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
The streets are deserted in Wuhan, which has been under lockdown since January 23. Photo: AP
Fifteen days after Wuhan – ground zero of the coronavirus outbreak – was placed under an unprecedented lockdown, the picture is bleak.

The streets remain eerily quiet in the central Chinese city that is home to 11 million people – more than New York or London. And people continue to fall ill, but they are struggling to get much-needed treatment and supplies.

All public transport into and out of the city, including trains, buses and ferries, stopped at 10am on January 23. Outbound flights were cancelled, private cars were ordered off the roads, and inner city public transport was also brought to a halt.

Advertisement

As the deadly virus continued to spread, at least 15 other cities across Hubei province were also locked down in the world’s biggest ever quarantine effort that is affecting more than 50 million people.

The pneumonia-like illness has infected more than 34,000 people and killed 700 since the outbreak began in December, according to the latest official figures. More than 22,000 of those patients are in Hubei, while 618 of the deaths were also in the province. Wuhan and the neighbouring cities of Xiaogan and Huanggang, which have also been closed off, are the worst affected.

As the death toll continues to mount in Wuhan and the other cities under lockdown, questions have been raised over whether the drastic measures have left residents in a worse position given the chronic shortage of hospital beds and medical supplies in the province.

‘Open up these cities’

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x