Advertisement
Advertisement
Coronavirus pandemic
Get more with myNEWS
A personalised news feed of stories that matter to you
Learn more
Vice-Premier Sun Chunlan has been the face of the Politburo in Wuhan for more than a month, and she’s under mounting pressure. Illustration: Lau Ka-kuen

In the firing line: the women in China’s war on the coronavirus

  • Vice-Premier Sun Chunlan has been the face of the Politburo in Wuhan for more than a month, and she’s under mounting pressure
  • She may be seen as more able to win trust in a country that usually ‘relies more on the men for their aggression and confidence to rule’

China’s former leader Mao Zedong famously declared that “women hold up half the sky” – a propaganda slogan first used in 1955 to encourage more of them to work in rural cooperatives, plough the fields, plant rice and help boost agricultural output.

In the country’s war on the coronavirus, women are taking on the tough jobs and holding up half, or even more, of the sky, analysts and feminists say – though they are also in the firing line for blame, and at the centre of a controversial state media campaign.

The highest profile is Sun Chunlan, vice-premier in charge of culture, education and public health and the only woman in the ruling Communist Party’s 25-member Politburo. The 70-year-old has spent more than a month on the front line in Wuhan, Hubei province, where the new virus strain first emerged in December, leading the government’s response on the ground.
She has been the stern face of the Politburo in the crisis, seen in state media talking to medical staff, stressing the importance of admitting patients to hospital and treating them as quickly as possible, checking on progress of new facilities being built, and warning local officials that “there must be no deserters, or they will be nailed to the pillar of historical shame forever”.
Vice-Premier Sun Chunlan visits the Huazhong University of Science and Technology in Wuhan on Saturday. Photo: Xinhua

Ding Xiangyang, deputy secretary general of the State Council, China’s cabinet, reinforced Sun’s message to Hubei officials at a press conference in Wuhan on February 20.

“The whole commanding system needs to improve its efficiency. If the system continues to work as if it’s business as usual, it can’t be called ‘wartime’ and we can’t win this battle,” Ding said. “Vice-Premier Sun Chunlan has asked everyone involved to rectify this.”

As the highest ranking official in the epicentre, Sun is under mounting pressure – and bearing the brunt of the criticism – over the epidemic that has killed over 3,100 people and infected more than 90,000, most of them in Hubei, and thrown Beijing into its worst crisis for decades.

But although she is at the heart of the crisis, state media coverage of Sun’s leadership has been limited, and President Xi Jinping is believed to be making the decisions on important matters, analysts say.

According to an internal speech by Xi released in mid-February, the president “issued demands … about the work to prevent and control” the coronavirus outbreak as early as January 7, during a meeting of the Politburo Standing Committee, China’s top political body.

“I have at every moment monitored the spread of the epidemic and progress in efforts to curtail it, constantly issuing verbal orders and also instructions,” Xi said of his involvement in the crisis.

Steve Tsang, director of the SOAS China Institute at the University of London, said while Xi was pulling the strings in Beijing, other leaders were taking care of public security, foreign policy, propaganda and other issues the top leadership saw as more important than what Sun was doing on the ground.

But it was her role in Wuhan that took courage and strength, according to Dali Yang, a political scientist at the University of Chicago.

“And the devil is in the detail,” Yang said. “Since Sun is in charge of the daily operations for public health affairs, she becomes an easy target – someone who can be blamed for all kinds of problems.”

Sun, who started her working life at a clock factory in the northeastern province of Liaoning, is following in the footsteps of another woman vice-premier, Wu Yi. Back in 2003, it was Wu who led the battle against the severe acute respiratory syndrome (Sars) epidemic, which claimed the lives of more than 800 people. Known as China’s “Iron Lady” for her toughness, Wu told media after Sars that heading up the task force handling the epidemic had been an extremely stressful time. China was heavily criticised for withholding information about the outbreak.
As vice-premier back in 2003, “Iron Lady” Wu Yi led the battle against Sars. Photo: SCMP

According to the World Bank, just 23.9 per cent of parliamentary seats across the globe are held by women. In China, it is much worse – the country has had just six women in its Politburo since 1949.

China was ranked 95th in the world for political involvement of women by the World Economic Forum’s “Global Gender Gap Report 2020”. Women hold only two cabinet-level positions and account for about a quarter of the legislature, the National People’s Congress. China’s similarly populous neighbour India, by comparison, takes 18th spot, while Iceland is at No 1.

Hu Xingdou, an independent political scientist, said women politicians were seen as more able to win the understanding and trust of ordinary people during a time of crisis.

“But most of the time, China relies more on the men for their aggression and confidence to rule the country,” Hu said.

Apart from Sun, other women have taken important roles in Wuhan. Zhang Jixian was one of the first doctors to sound the alarm about the new virus back in December. The 54-year-old head of respiratory medicine at the Hubei Provincial Hospital of Integrated Chinese and Western Medicine reported cases to her superiors at the end of December after she noticed a pattern. Her hospital then contacted the local and provincial health authorities.
Leading epidemiologist Li Lanjuan, 73, has also been seen in state media – as part of a panel of experts from the National Health Commission, she was the one who explained the controversial decision to lock down millions of people in Wuhan on January 23. She told state broadcaster CCTV the decision was made after cases emerged of people travelling from Hubei to other provinces, where they transmitted the virus to others. She said they were worried the situation would worsen with millions of people on the move ahead of the Lunar New Year on January 25.
But most of the media attention has gone to her fellow epidemiologist Zhong Nanshan, 83, a hero of the Sars crisis who has been explaining the situation in press briefings. Li Wenliang, meanwhile, the 34-year-old doctor whistle-blower who was silenced by police when he tried to raise the alarm and died after contracting the virus, has been a focus of public grief and anger over the authorities’ handling of the crisis.
State media has tried to turn attention to the many women working as doctors and nurses treating coronavirus patients, but efforts to include them in a propaganda campaign have backfired.

“Women are playing very important roles in the battle against this disease, doing their jobs at a crucial time,” said Feng Yuan, co-founder of Equality, a non-governmental organisation in Beijing.

“But I’m disappointed to see some media focusing on their conventional gender roles and portraying them as the weaker sex while highlighting unnecessary personal sacrifices they were forced to make.”

Reports last month of women nurses from a number of cities having their heads shaved for “convenience” and to help control the spread of the disease before they travelled to Wuhan to lend a hand provoked outrage online. Their hospitals said the women were “willing” to do this, but some of the nurses were seen in video footage weeping while their hair was cut off.

That came after CCTV on February 11 described nurse Zhao Yu as “a great mother and angel in a white gown” for continuing to work in the emergency ward of a military hospital in Wuhan while heavily pregnant. The broadcaster said Zhao had insisted on working despite being 20 days away from giving birth, in a report hailing her devotion to her job – but social media users raised concern about the situation and the clip was withdrawn from CCTV’s website.

The next day, Wuhan Evening News praised a 27-year-old nurse who had returned to work 10 days after surgery following a miscarriage – again it did not get the intended response online.

Lu Pin, a feminist campaigner, said it was “inhuman” to pressure or encourage women to make these personal sacrifices.

“It shed light on the social environment Chinese women live in. It’s a cruel reality that there’s a lack of physical autonomy and insufficient protection at work, among other things,” said Lu, who lives in New York. “Their status is incompatible with the contribution women have made to the country.”

Purchase the China AI Report 2020 brought to you by SCMP Research and enjoy a 20% discount (original price US$400). This 60-page all new intelligence report gives you first-hand insights and analysis into the latest industry developments and intelligence about China AI. Get exclusive access to our webinars for continuous learning, and interact with China AI executives in live Q&A. Offer valid until 31 March 2020.

This article appeared in the South China Morning Post print edition as: Women in the firing line
Post