‘I can never be happy again’: grieving Wuhan families say China is blocking coronavirus lawsuits
- Relatives of people who died from Covid-19 claim cases have been abruptly rejected and some have faced pressure from the authorities not to file
- They accuse the Wuhan and Hubei governments of concealing the outbreak when it first emerged, not alerting the public and bungling the response
But they have had their lawsuits abruptly rejected, dozens of others face pressure from authorities not to file, and lawyers are being warned against helping them, according to people involved in the effort.
The families accuse the Wuhan and Hubei provincial governments of concealing the outbreak when it first emerged there late last year, failing to alert the public, and bungling the response, allowing Covid-19 to explode out of control.
It has killed nearly 3,900 in the city and over 900,000 globally so far.
“They say the epidemic was a natural calamity. But these serious outcomes are man-made, and you need to find who’s to blame,” said Zhong, 67.
“Our family is shattered. I can never be happy again.”
Families of coronavirus victims accuse China of blocking coronavirus lawsuits
At least five lawsuits have been filed with the Wuhan Intermediate People’s Court, said Zhang Hai, whose elderly father died of the virus and who has emerged as a vocal advocate and spokesman for families of virus victims.
Plaintiffs are each seeking around 2 million yuan (US$295,000) in damages and a public apology.
But the court has rejected suits on unspecified procedural grounds, said Yang Zhanqing, a veteran Chinese activist now in the US.
Yang, who is coordinating two dozen lawyers in China who are secretly advising families, said the rejections had come via curt phone calls – not through official written explanations, as legally required – apparently to avoid a paper trail.
Staff at the Wuhan court refused requests for comment.
The virus emerged in Wuhan last December but city authorities initially dragged their feet, pressuring whistle-blowing doctors to keep quiet.
The Communist Party continues to downplay responsibility, even questioning whether the pathogen originated in China, while trumpeting its later success in suppressing domestic infections.
But Zhong tells a different story.
By late January, the contagion was spreading rapidly in Wuhan, but officials had still issued no citywide alarm.
China’s coronavirus dead honoured by Taoist priest with ceremonies using memorial tablets
With the extended Lunar New Year festival approaching, Zhong and her son Peng Yi – a 39-year-old primary schoolteacher – happily shopped at jam-packed stores. Millions of others left Wuhan for the holiday, taking the infection global.
“We had no idea the buses were full of the virus ... So we went out every day. We didn’t even know about masks,” Zhong said.
On January 24, as Wuhan finally began locking down, she and Peng fell ill. She soon recovered, but he worsened.
Fear gripped their household, which included Zhong’s husband, Peng’s wife, and his seven-year-old daughter.
For the next two agonising weeks, they spent long hours in overwhelmed hospitals begging to get him admitted, but without a positive result – and with testing kits scarce – he was repeatedly turned away.
Peng was finally admitted to hospital on February 6.
His family never saw him alive again. He died on a respirator two weeks later.
“He must have been so scared, so unhappy, with no family around. I can’t imagine how sad he was,” said Zhong, breaking down repeatedly.
“Did he call out ‘Mother’? ‘Father’? I don’t know.”
A look at China’s industrial and transport hub Wuhan before and after its coronavirus lockdown
Zhang Hai believes his father was infected at a Wuhan hospital during treatment for an unrelated ailment.
He says authorities are waging a campaign to discredit him, suspending his social media accounts and circulating disinformation that the legal efforts are a scam to bilk families.
Others also have reported official intimidation, and next-of-kin chat groups have been infiltrated by police, Zhang alleged, blaming Wuhan’s government.
“They know if I succeed in filing a case, many other families will sue, too,” he said.
Wuhan’s government did not respond to requests for comment.
Zhang said dozens of bereaved relatives had coalesced in chat groups, but most were fearful of taking action.
With his initial suit in Wuhan rejected, Zhang filed recently with a higher, provincial-level court. Zhong, the elderly pensioner, plans to do the same.
Yang, the US-based activist, believes it “very likely” the government will quietly meet some families’ demands eventually, though a public apology is inconceivable.
Until then, Zhang intends to appeal all the way to China’s highest court in Beijing, regardless of the personal risks.
“My father is my motivation,” he said.