Advertisement
HKDSE
Hong KongEducation

Hong Kong exam authority holds marathon meeting over whether to void controversial history question as sensitive issue crops up on another paper

  • Authority locked in talks over whether to scrap question on Sino-Japanese relations, but no decision had been publicised as of Thursday night
  • Sensitive issue re-emerges on another paper, leading some Diploma of Secondary Education candidates to fear more uncertainty

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Hong Kong’s Examinations and Assessment Authority is discussing how to respond to a request from the Education Bureau to invalidate a test question. Photo: Handout
Chan Ho-him
Hong Kong’s exam authority held a marathon meeting on Thursday over the Education Bureau’s unprecedented request to scrap a controversial history question on Sino-Japanese relations, as candidates feared an escalation of the row when the sensitive issue appeared again on another paper.

Thousands of Diploma of Secondary Education (DSE) candidates sitting the Chinese history exam on Thursday were asked if they agreed with the stance taken by a propaganda poster released during the Japanese occupation of China, leading some students to brace themselves for a repeat of the controversy blighting the earlier assessment.

The question on the world history paper, which was put to 5,200 candidates on May 14, asked them to comment on whether Japan “did more good than harm” to China between 1900 and 1945, based on two excerpts of reading material and their own knowledge.

A source familiar with Hong Kong’s Examinations and Assessment Authority (HKEAA) told the South China Morning Post that Thursday’s meeting – the second held since Monday – involved a discussion over several hours that “touched on many different issues and considerations”.

Advertisement

No further details of the talks had been publicly released as of Thursday night.

On Monday, a six-hour meeting of the HKEAA council ended without a decision being reached over whether the question should be invalidated.

Advertisement

The Education Bureau issued a statement later on Monday night, reminding the statutory body of its duty to comply with directives issued by the chief executive.

City leader Carrie Lam Cheng Yuet-ngor on Tuesday called the question “a mistake” and hinted she could use her office’s powers to invalidate the question if necessary to “safeguard the quality and aims of education and protect students”.
Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x