Hong Kong MTR

Independent probe into MTR’s Sha Tin-Central rail link platform scandal possible, Hong Kong No 2 official Matthew Cheung says

The chief secretary also spoke up for the transport minister, saying he did not know about a subcontractor’s request for a meeting that critics allege could have shed light on the scandal earlier

PUBLISHED : Saturday, 09 June, 2018, 1:57pm
UPDATED : Saturday, 09 June, 2018, 11:08pm

The government is considering establishing a judge-led committee to investigate the HK$97.1 billion (US$12 billion) Sha Tin-Central rail link’s corner-cutting scandal, Hong Kong’s No 2 official said, as lawmakers intensified calls for action against the MTR Corporation.

“The government does not rule out conducting an independent investigation,” Chief Secretary Matthew Cheung Kin-chung said on Saturday, adding that the public would be informed when it made a decision.

Five lawmakers from both sides of the political divide had earlier on Saturday urged Chief Executive Carrie Lam Cheng Yuet-ngor to launch an independent inquest into the rail giant’s lapses in documenting faulty work in the city’s most expensive rail project to date.

MTR Corp identifies subcontractor in platform work scandal

Last week, the semi-privatised corporation admitted a subcontractor cut corners when carrying out its HK$5.2 billion contract to build platforms under the existing Hung Hom station for the new rail link.

It subsequently named Fang Sheung Construction as the culprit, saying its workers cut steel bars used in construction to fake proper installation in September 2015, when they should have been screwed by hand into couplers on the platforms. The fault was rectified in August 2016.

Fang Sheung is voluntarily registered with the Construction Industry Council as a subcontractor specialising in “reinforcement bar fixing”. It was hired by Leighton Contractors (Asia), which won the main contract for the rail link project in 2013.

The MTR Corporation is due to release findings from its own probe next Friday, after the government demanded it do so and also arrange for an independent expert to conduct load testing on the platforms.

MTR Corp had vowed to take legal action if any evidence of fraud was uncovered, as it fended off accusations last week of a cover-up.

But on a Saturday morning radio show, pro-establishment lawmakers Michael Tien Puk-sun and Tony Tse Wai-chuen, alongside Democratic Party’s Helena Wong Pik-wan, insisted an independent investigation was necessary.

The heads of Legco’s transport panel – Democratic Alliance for the Betterment and Progress of Hong Kong lawmaker Ben Chan Han-pan and Democratic Party legislator Lam Cheuk-ting – took the same stance on a separate programme.

“You can clearly see that the government’s monitoring of the MTR Corp is ‘left hand passing to the right’ – if you sign off [on a project], I’ll do so too,” Tien said, adding that the same could be true with the rail giant’s relationship with Leighton Contractors (Asia).

The government’s monitoring of the MTR Corp is ‘left hand passing to the right’ – if you sign off [on a project], I’ll do too
Michael Tien, lawmaker

The city has set up committees in the past to review major incidents involving public safety, including after the 2012 Lamma ferry disaster that killed 39 people, the 2015 lead-in-water scandal in public housing estates and most recently, after a horrific bus accident in Tai Po that claimed 19 lives in February this year.

Wong also stressed the need for lawmakers to conduct a parallel investigation in the Legislative Council, though this move was not supported by the pro-establishment camp. Localist lawmaker Cheng Chung-tai’s motion to set up a select committee to investigate the incident was shot down in a Legco House Committee meeting on Friday.

On Saturday, Cheung also spoke up for transport chief Frank Chan Fan, whom he said “really didn’t know” about a request made by Leighton’s subcontractor’s, China Technology Corp, for a meeting with officials last year.

The Transport and Housing Bureau earlier said the faulty steel bars incident was not reported to them but confirmed on Saturday morning that China Technology Corp, tasked with concrete pouring after the installation of the bars, had on September 15 last year requested a meeting with the bureau’s Highways Department, Leighton and the MTR Corp.

However, the subcontractor gave no specific details about the meeting agenda and then mysteriously withdrew its request three days later, saying the issue had been “resolved”. The bureau asked MTR Corp about the matter, but the rail company said it needed more information before it could comment.

“As China Technology Corp did not provide relevant information at the time, the Highways Department could not follow up,” the bureau spokesman said.

In a press statement issued on Saturday night, the bureau added that as the meeting was on “technical issues”, Chan was not informed about it.

When it was contacted by the Post, a representative of China Technology Corp said its role in the project ended in February last year but it did “outstanding works and defect rectification” in September.

He said: “We were at that moment ready to be fully demobilised … when Leighton was keeping ‘arrogant mode’ [and] denying everything, we thus [proposed] a joint meeting to settle the scandal properly.”

But Leighton’s “top figures” instead called for meeting with the subcontractor’s managing director, the spokesman continued, and they“agreed [on] certain remedial procedures to settle the scandal”. “However, we are not certain if the remedial works [has been carried out] yet,” he said.

The Sha Tin-Central line has been troubled by cost overruns and delays. Services on the Tuen Ma line are due to begin in 2019, and on the cross-harbour section between Hung Hom and Admiralty in 2021.