Get more with myNEWS
A personalised news feed of stories that matter to you
Learn more
The husband of Hong Kong superstar Sammi Cheng, Andy Hui apologies for his actions after a video circulated of him in a vehicle with another woman. Photo: Felix Wong

Racy video of ‘queen of Canto-pop’ Sammi Cheng’s husband Andy Hui in back of vehicle with another woman sparks privacy concerns over on-board cameras

  • Chinese-language news site Apple Daily releases 16-minute video of pair kissing on journey from Tai Hang to Lei Yue Mun
  • Former privacy commissioner and barrister says driver and Apple Daily run risk of breaching Hong Kong law

A racy video clip showing Hong Kong superstar Sammi Cheng Sau-man’s singer husband Andy Hui Chi-on getting intimate with another woman in a vehicle has sparked a wave of privacy concerns about hidden cameras installed by drivers.

The debate for greater safeguards came on Tuesday as Chinese-language news site Apple Daily released a 16-minute video caught by an on-board camera showing Hui, 51, allegedly cuddling and kissing TVB actress Jacqueline Wong, 30.

The clip showed the pair kissed about 20 times during a ride from Tai Hang in Causeway Bay to Lei Yue Mun.

They left the vehicle together but it was not clear whether it was a taxi, hired car or a private car.

Not all see funny side of memes about cheating Hong Kong star Andy Hui

After the video went viral, Hui broke down in tears at a press conference on Tuesday evening, apologising for hurting those who love him and begging the public to give him time to regain his lost soul.

I have done something irreparable and unforgivable … I am sorry, Sammi
Andy Hui, singer

“I would like to say it from the bottom of my heart to everybody that I am sorry. My deep apologies to my family, my friends and those who love me. I have done something irreparable and unforgivable … I am sorry, Sammi,” he said.

Cheng, 46, dubbed the queen of Canto-pop, has a concert in the city in July.

Hui, who married Cheng in 2014 after an on-and-off relationship for more than two decades, admitted he had consumed a lot of alcohol that had caused him to lose his sense of mind and have some “lecherous thoughts”.

Queen of Canto-pop Sammi Cheng will play a concert in Hong Kong in July. Photo: AFP

“But I know this is absolutely not an excuse. I deeply regret it … I feel I am very disgusting, revolting and strange,” he said.

“I have made those around me suffer so much. I really hope those who are hurt by me are well.”

Hui said he would suspend all his work until he “recovers his true self”.

“At this moment I am a person without soul,” he said. “I am a rotten person.”

Former privacy commissioner and barrister Allan Chiang Yam-wang said the vehicle driver and Apple Daily ran the risk of breaching the city’s privacy law, which took into account some key legal principles no matter which type of vehicle or organisation.

“First of all, the driver needs to notify the passengers there is a camera inside the vehicle so they can choose not to get on the car. Failure to do so is already a breach of the privacy law,” Chiang said.

“Secondly, does the driver have a lawful ground to collect the personal data? A legitimate reason such as for the sake of his profession to take the video without the parties’ consent.”

A driver needs to notify passengers there is a camera in the vehicle … Failure to do so is a breach of the privacy law
Allan Chiang, former privacy commissioner

Chiang said the third factor was whether the collection of personal data was fair to the parties.

“If the video allows other people to easily identify the filmed parties’ identities, the driver runs a higher risk of breaching the privacy law,” he said.

He pointed out Apple Daily also ran a legal risk for circulating the video unless it could prove to the privacy commissioner it was doing so in the public interest.

However, Chiang said that only the affected parties could launch a complaint to the privacy commissioner, who would first issue an enforcement notice to the offender advising him to stop the illegal act.

Why Hong Kong privacy watchdog has all but given up on data breach complaints

Only if the offender breached the privacy law again would the commissioner institute a prosecution against him.

Privacy Commissioner Stephen Wong said a taxi was defined as a semi-private place and a driver should abide by the privacy law if a camera was installed.

Taxi drivers should make their passengers aware an on-board camera is in the vehicle so they can choose not to get in the vehicle. Photo: May Tse

A Transport Department spokesman said a guideline was being drafted for the taxi sector regarding installing such devices in their vehicles because of privacy concerns.

Civic Party lawmaker Jeremy Tam Man-ho, who is also a member for the government-appointed Committee on Taxi Service Quality, warned there must be proper security measures to prevent cabbies from gaining access to the personal data of their passengers.

Taxi drivers clock up record 11,000 complaints in 2018

“Drivers would be easily tempted into sharing videos of famous people caught on their cameras,” he said.

“There must be some security measures to make sure that drivers could not easily gain access to the passengers’ personal data. I have proposed that the memory stick could be installed into the taxi’s meter or officially encrypted so the content is only accessible to law enforcement agencies,” he said.

This article appeared in the South China Morning Post print edition as: Racy video of Andy Hui puts privacy in spotlight