Advertisement
Hong Kong protests
Hong KongLaw and Crime

Criminal lawyer Edwin Choy opens up on resignation from Hong Kong Bar Association, saying his outlook on protest violence diverged too much from others

  • Many protesters ‘have been stirred into abandoning reason and replacing it with barbarism’, says Edwin Choy, who represented Occupy leaders
  • Destructive acts serve ‘no meaningful purpose’, while Hong Kong is ‘engulfed in the flames of senseless nihilism’, he says.

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Edwin Choy says he was convinced his outlook diverged too much from that of the Bar Council to remain among its ranks. Photo: Winson Wong
Chris Lau

A top criminal lawyer has said he resigned as the vice-chairman of the Hong Kong Bar Association over its failure to condemn protesters’ violent acts during the ongoing anti-government demonstrations.

Two days after it was revealed that Edwin Choy Wai-bond, 48, had parted ways with the association’s executive office, the Bar Council, the lawyer on Monday wrote to the Post to offer his account.
Commenting on the recent protests, he said while he appreciated many youths for holding fast to their political ideals, many others “have been stirred into abandoning reason and replacing it with barbarism”, with their peaceful demeanour morphing into destructive conduct “far beyond the set boundaries laid down by the law”.
Advertisement

“As it became increasingly apparent to me that a substantial majority of my colleagues on the Bar Council remained highly reticent to state, with unequivocal clarity, that both the rioters and those who proffer excuses on their behalf should be condemned, I was convinced that my outlook diverged too much from [that of] the council for me to remain among its ranks,” he said.

The veteran legal practitioner, who became a senior counsel last year, had earlier represented leaders of the 2014 Occupy protests. He also defended pro-independence activist Edward Leung Tin-kei, when he was charged over the riot that gripped Mong Kok, a popular shopping district, in 2016.
Advertisement

A legal source told the Post that while the association had issued three statements to denounce protesters in the past months, Choy wanted one more but did not get enough support.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x