Advertisement
Advertisement
Hong Kong protests
Get more with myNEWS
A personalised news feed of stories that matter to you
Learn more
Clashes break out during a stand-off between radical protesters and riot police at Hong Kong Polytechnic University in Hung Hom on November 18. Photo: Sam Tsang

Campus battlegrounds: a blow to image and appeal of Hong Kong’s once-peaceful universities

  • Campus activism is not new, but the extent of vandalism and wanton damage is shocking
  • Fear of violence likely to deter mainland Chinese and foreign students from enrolling
Over five months, Hong Kong’s anti-government protests turned from peaceful marches to fierce clashes between increasingly violent masked radicals and police, who responded with tear gas, rubber bullets, live rounds and mass arrests.
The action stayed mostly on the street, as well as in MTR stations and shopping malls. But in November, university campuses suddenly became the scene of wanton vandalism, destruction and battles between riot police and radical protesters.
At Polytechnic University (PolyU), which has seen the most dramatic action, student Chan, 20, refused to heed police’s call to surrender and said she saw nothing wrong with protesters taking their cause to campuses. “Universities are places where anyone can voice opinions and people from different places can come,” Chan, who asked to be identified only by her surname, said.

Social sciences major Wong, 25, who also gave only his surname, disagreed. “They are fighting for their own cause at the expense of people who just want to study in peace,” the Hongkonger said. “Universities should be about academics, not activism. Not that the two can’t coexist, but there are plenty of ways to voice opinions. Being violent is not the behaviour of scholars.”

Fiona Sun looks at Hong Kong’s universities, which include some of the world’s best, the protests, and some of the damage done to the campuses this month.

A water cannon arrives to disperse radical protesters from the Hong Kong Polytechnic University in Hung Hom on November 17. Photo: Sam Tsang

How many universities are there in Hong Kong?

There are 22 higher education institutions that award degrees. Eight are funded by the University Grants Committee (UGC): the University of Hong Kong (HKU), Chinese University of Hong Kong (CUHK), Hong Kong University of Science and Technology (HKUST), Hong Kong Polytechnic University (PolyU), City University of Hong Kong (CityU), Hong Kong Baptist University (HKBU), Lingnan University (LingU) and the Education University of Hong Kong (EdUHK).

Another 13 are self-financing, including the Open University of Hong Kong and Hong Kong Shue Yan University. The Hong Kong Academy for Performing Arts, is publicly funded.

More than 8,000 petrol bombs primed ‘found in weapons factory at Chinese University’

HKU, established in 1911, is the city’s oldest university. The newest is UOW College Hong Kong, a self-financing institution added to the list of degree-awarding institutions from the 2019-2020 academic year.

In the closely watched QS World University Rankings, three Hong Kong universities ranked among the global top 50 in 2019: HKU fared best in 25th place, HKUST was 37th and CUHK was 49th. In the Asian rankings, HKU ranked second, just behind the National University of Singapore, while HKUST was seventh and CUHK, ninth.

How many university students are there?

More than 100,000 students were enrolled in the eight UGC-funded universities in the 2018-2019 academic year. Some 86,000 were undergraduates, about 10,800 were in graduate programmes and the rest were in sub-degree programmes.

Nearly 83,000 were local students. The number of non-local students has risen over the past five years, from 15,151 in 2014-2015 to 18,060 in 2018-2019, according to the UGC.

Missing chemicals from Hong Kong university laboratories spark safety fears

Most of the non-local students in 2018-2019, were from mainland China (12,322), followed by 1,479 from South Korea, 731 from Taiwan, 669 from India, 565 from Indonesia and 406 from Malaysia. There were 108 students from the United States and 34 from Britain.

The main university entrance examination for local students is the Hong Kong Diploma of Secondary Education (HKDSE). Most take four core subjects – Chinese language, English language, mathematics and liberal studies – and two or three elective subjects.

Clashes break out at Chinese University of Hong Kong in Sha Tin as riot police and radical protesters exchange tear gas and petrol bombs on November 12. Photo: Sam Tsang

How did campuses become protest flashpoints?

Anti-government protests which began in June moved to university campuses after Chow Tsz-lok, 22, a second-year computer science student of HKUST, died on November 8. He injured his head severely after falling from the third floor to the second of a car park in Tseung Kwan O on November 4, while a clash was taking place between protesters and police in a nearby area.

The exact circumstances of how Chow fell remain unclear, but protesters accused police of firing tear gas into the area during a dispersal operation and obstructing paramedics from reaching Chow in time. His death prompted protesters to go on a rampage on the HKUST campus, vandalising university president Wei Shyy’s residence, and trashing cafeterias, a Starbucks outlet and a Bank of China branch.

Protests then spread to more campuses, and escalating clashes on November 11 led to police entering and firing tear gas at CUHK, PolyU and HKU – the first time such mob dispersal methods were adopted in tertiary institutions.

The Chinese University campus in Sha Tin was occupied by radical protesters for four days. Photo: Felix Wong

Which campuses were worst hit?

At HKU in Pok Fu Lam, protesters set fire to the MTR station, piled up barricades at the campus gates and threw petrol bombs from a footbridge at people trying to clear the roads.

Things were worse on the CUHK campus in Sha Tin, which was occupied by radical protesters for four days. During a stand-off around Bridge No 2 near the university – which overlooks the Tolo Highway, a main road in the New Territories – protesters threw petrol bombs, bricks and other objects, and police responded with tear gas, rubber bullets and beanbag rounds. More than 8,000 petrol bombs were found at CUHK.

Are Hong Kong’s universities becoming ‘weapons factories’?

The situation was the worst at PolyU in Hung Hom. On November 17, after a day of violent clashes, police locked down the campus, blocking all exits. More than 1,000 masked radicals and their supporters engaged in fierce clashes with police that day. An officer was pierced in his calf by an arrow shot by someone in the mob, and an armoured vehicle was set ablaze after being pelted with petrol bombs.

Established in 1937, and ranked fifth among Hong Kong universities and 31st in Asia in 2019 QS rankings, PolyU has been shut down since November 17. Police ordered everyone on campus to come out and face arrest, while several protesters tried various methods to escape. About 75 secondary school heads and teachers, as well as political and legal heavyweights stepped in to help, persuading the majority to leave. But dozens continue to hold out on campus, including radicals who vowed to fight to the end.

Is campus activism something new in Hong Kong?

The city’s universities are peaceful places of learning most of the time, but they are not new to student activism and protests.

During the 2014 Occupy protests, when parts of Hong Kong were shut down by protesters for 79 days, university students joined in a class boycott from September 22 to 26, organised jointly by two student groups – the Hong Kong Federation of Students (HKFS) and Scholarism. Fighting for democracy and universal suffrage, students and teachers wore white shirts and yellow ribbons on September 22 and gathered at the University Mall of CUHK, where the class boycott officially kicked off.

More Hong Kong protesters leave Polytechnic University in surrender

In 1989, Hong Kong university students supported students in Beijing who were protesting for democracy and against corruption at Tiananmen Square. In May that year, thousands of Hong Kong students took part in a massive demonstration in the city. Hong Kong students also raised funds and travelled to Beijing to support the protesters there. Beijing’s bloody military crackdown in Tiananmen Square on June 4, 1989, left several hundred protesters, or more, dead. In Hong Kong, HKFS-affiliated students boycotted classes. University students have been prominent since then at the annual June 4 vigil held at Victoria Park to remember those who died in the crackdown.

Anti-government protesters set up roadblocks outside the Hong Kong Baptist University in Kowloon Tong on November 14. Photo: Xiaomei Chen

Will protests hurt the universities’ reputation?

The strong anti-mainland aspect of the ongoing protests has left mainland Chinese feeling vulnerable. When campuses became flashpoints, mainland students feared for their safety and many decided to leave Hong Kong. A group of mainland students fled the CUHK campus by police boat on November 13.

Zhou, 28, a CUHK doctoral student from the mainland, is still in Hong Kong. Asking to be identified only by his surname, he said he chose to come to Hong Kong because of the city’s high academic standards, but the campus protests had disrupted his studies and research. Most of his mainland classmates have already gone home.

Police surround university campus occupied by radicals after day of fierce clashes

“Universities should create an environment for students and scholars to ensure that they can contribute to society,” he said. “The protests have seriously affected our use of libraries and other resources. It has hurt the spirit of the universities.”

Educator Tai Hay-lap, a former Education Commission member, said universities were the places where human talent was cultivated. He said the protests on campuses will make Hong Kong’s universities less attractive to students and scholars from the mainland and elsewhere. He expected to see a decline in the number of non-local students in the next academic year.

He said Hong Kong’s universities had been losing their diversity and inclusiveness, with xenophobia and cultural conflict springing up on campuses. “The physical damage will be restored sooner or later, but the cultural divide will take time to recover,” he said.

Post