Advertisement
Advertisement
Hong Kong protests
Get more with myNEWS
A personalised news feed of stories that matter to you
Learn more
Hong Kong riot police arrest protesters following clashes during an anti-extradition bill march in September. Photo: K.Y. Cheng

Hong Kong police ‘systematically infringed’ human rights of protest arrestees, local group argues in report destined for UN

  • Civil Rights Observer, which interviewed 45 arrestees, suggests force may have violated international treaties against torture
  • One man told the group he was beaten with batons and had his head repeatedly slammed into the door of a police van, necessitating a hospital trip
A local human rights group has accused the Hong Kong police force of beating and treating arrestees inhumanely during last year’s anti-government protests, in a report they will submit to the United Nations.

Civil Rights Observer, which published the findings of its months-long investigation on Tuesday, interviewed 45 arrestees for the report, which suggests the force may have violated international treaties against torture.

“The fact that these cases happened repeatedly has demonstrated that it is not just a matter of individual officers,” the group’s Icarus Wong Ho-yin said. “They are allowed or implicitly allowed by their seniors – this is a systemic infringement of human rights.”

The Post has contacted the force seeking comment.

An anti-government protester is detained by Special Tactical Squad officers in Wan Chai in October. Photo: Winson Wong

About 8,000 people – some 40 per cent of them students – were arrested during months of social unrest that erupted last June over a now-withdrawn extradition bill, while at least 1,365 people were prosecuted.

Those interviewed by Civil Rights Observer were arrested at protests that took place between July and November. Real names and exact times of arrests were not included in the report to avoid potential retribution.

Coronavirus: Hongkonger without travel history confirmed as infected after 22 days without any new local cases

Thirteen of the arrestees reported severe assault or injuries at the hands of the police; 16 said access to their lawyers was delayed; and three claimed they were sexually assaulted.

One of the alleged victims, identified by the pseudonym Gabriel in the report, accused officers of planting a brick on him and repeatedly hitting his fingers, arm, pelvis and head with batons. Officers also slammed his head into the door of a police van a dozen times, he claimed.

A January anti-government protest descends into chaos in Central after police ask organisers to end the rally early. Photo: Felix Wong

After being taken to the station, three officers then took turns hitting him in the stomach for 15 minutes, while another officer covered his eyes, slapped his face and kicked his abdomen as he was questioned, according to the report. Gabriel was subsequently sent to the hospital directly from the police station and treated in a neurosurgery ward.

Another person, identified as Jason, claimed he was taken to a police station for taking video footage at a protest. He alleged that a plain-clothes officer then hit him in the head and shined a flashlight in his eye for about 15 seconds.

Police chief Chris Tang admits handling of journalists covering Mother’s Day demonstrations was unsatisfactory

“Don’t you like to shine light at things? If I do this to you for a minute, you will become blind,” he quoted the officer as saying.

Wong said the alleged incidents could amount to prima facie cases of assault occasioning actual bodily harm as well as violations of international human rights agreement, such as the UN Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment.

A new report by human rights group Civil Rights Observer accuses the Hong Kong Police Force of beating arrestees while in custody. Photo: Sam Tsang

Andrew Shum Wai-nam, another member of the group, said: “We urged the government to set up an independent inquiry to look into the allegations against police brutality, as well as to hold individual officers involved accountable.”

He added that surveillance cameras should be installed inside police vehicles to prevent any maltreatment, something recommended by a 2018 coroner’s inquest that followed the death of a man inside a police vehicle.

Hong Kong government to expand HK$80 billion wage subsidy scheme to include seniors and vulnerable

The group said it will submit the report to the United Nations Human Rights Committee – which is holding a hearing on Hong Kong next month – as well as legislatures in Britain and the United States.

Meanwhile, the pro-establishment camp, which has traditionally ignored meetings of UN bodies, has joined the fray this year.

Anti-government protesters hurl bricks toward water cannon trucks and an armoured vehicle as clashes break out between riot police and students near the Hong Kong Polytechnic University in Hung Hom in November. Photo: Sam Tsang

Hong Kong Higher Education Convergence, a Beijing-friendly group, has tabled a submission to the UN Human Rights Committee condemning violence committed by masked protesters last year.

It expressed support for the police in its submission, saying the force had used only necessary force to restore law and order and had not killed a single person – unlike protests in other countries.

The group also argued the city’s anti-terrorism laws were not comprehensive enough, saying police should be allowed to detain those suspected of terrorist activities for up to seven days as well as stop and search without grounds of suspicion.

Help us understand what you are interested in so that we can improve SCMP and provide a better experience for you. We would like to invite you to take this five-minute survey on how you engage with SCMP and the news.

Post