Advertisement
Advertisement
Accidents and personal safety in Hong Kong
Get more with myNEWS
A personalised news feed of stories that matter to you
Learn more
A deadly fire broke out at New Lucky House during the early hours of Wednesday morning. Photo: Jelly Tse

Owners of blaze-hit Hong Kong building in 16-year dispute over fire safety order

  • Head of local firefighters’ division also says unregistered structural changes found at 60-year-old New Lucky House, where fire claimed five lives and left 43 injured
  • Building’s owners’ corporation involved in at least two ongoing non-compliance cases dating as far back as 2008 related to need to upgrade protection measures
Wynna Wong
The Hong Kong building where a blaze left five people dead failed to comply with a fire safety order for 16 years due to a long-running dispute between owners over the necessary upgrade, a district councillor familiar with the situation said on Thursday.

The head of the local firefighters’ division also said a day after the blaze that New Lucky House had undergone unregistered structural changes, especially among its subdivided flats, that created additional obstacles for rescuers.

The fire at the 60-year-old commercial and residential building on Jordan Road also left 43 people injured, with eight in critical conditions, including a girl below the age of one.

The blaze has prompted an examination into the building’s history, with its owners’ corporation involved in at least two ongoing non-compliance cases dating as far back as 2008 involving the need to upgrade protection measures.

It had also met consultants over the years to discuss the issue.

Authorities have said five prosecutions were filed against owners in the past decade, with the charges related to obstruction of escape routes, failure to maintain fire fighting equipment and a lack of annual gear inspections.

Chris Ip Ngo-tung, a member of Yau Tsim Mong’s district council, said on Thursday that he had tried to work with the owners’ corporation in the past, but found the process was complicated by disputes “between various people”.

“There has been some chaos in terms of management, I would say,” he told a radio programme.

The building is home to hundreds of residents and includes 35 registered guest houses and about 100 subdivided flats. The building also has a gym, shops and offices, as well as several traditional Chinese medicine clinics.

The district councillor said he tried to help owners resolve the building’s compliance issues around 2018, but members were divided over whether to simply carry out the order or conduct major repair works.

Chris Ip, a member of Yau Tsim Mong’s district council, has said that he and his colleagues tried to help the building’s owners resolve compliance issues several years ago. Photo: Facebook/Chris Ip

“In fact, the disputes became quite severe,” he said. “They ended up refusing further assistance from we district councillors and government officers, so we had to drop the case.

“I don’t know what happened to them in the end, but we did remind them they needed to resolve the issue because orders from the Buildings Department cannot be ignored.”

A severe imbalance in various owners’ stakes also contributed to the lack of a unanimous decision and caused the problem to drag on for many years, he said.

Ip said older buildings in particular fuelled disagreements between owners since they also had to deal with maintenance issues.

“Owners have to raise funds together and also agree on a construction company and consultants. It can get quite difficult,” he added.

03:18

Hong Kong fire kills 5, injures dozens in Kowloon commercial and residential building

Hong Kong fire kills 5, injures dozens in Kowloon commercial and residential building

The district councillor said the increasingly high cost of upgrading fire prevention facilities and equipment, especially in the bidding process, had not helped.

He urged authorities to consider increasing the help available to owners, with the city home to many buildings more than 50 years old that should be included in a priority upgrade plan.

Lam Kin-kwan, commander of the Fire Services Department’s Kowloon South division, told the same radio programme that the presence of so many subdivided flats had inevitably hampered rescue efforts.

“It means there were more people at the scene … it can skew the occupation ratio,” he said.

The fire service commander said unregistered modifications to some internal structures had only increased the safety risks. Illegal changes were one line of investigation being pursued, he added.

Wednesday’s fire mainly affected the building’s first and second floors, as well as three staircases, Lam said.

He also said initial investigations uncovered an abundance of plastic items at the scene, including construction materials, that could have contributed to the thick smoke.

Some residents had also complained to the Post that guest houses left belongings in corridors, while the building’s safety equipment was of a very poor standard.

9