Advertisement
World

Mars attracts, but did Barack Obama pick the wrong planet for a manned expedition?

Instead of the Martian mission he touted this week, the US president should have considered Venus instead, one Nasa expert says

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
The surface of Venus is thoroughly inhospitable, but 50km up in its atmosphere, conditions are surprisingly close to those on Earth. Photo: Handout
The Washington Post

President John F. Kennedy made history in the 1960s when he kicked America’s space program into overdrive, resulting in history’s first manned mission to the moon.

And US President Barack Obama wants to do something similar: launch a major expedition to an unexplored body in the solar system, jump-start a frenzy of economic and scientific activity to help get us there, and claim lots of credit for creating jobs as well as promoting science and technology.

On Tuesday, Obama published an op-ed at CNN laying out his vision once again for visiting Mars.
Advertisement

“We have set a clear goal vital to the next chapter of America’s story in space: sending humans to Mars by the 2030s and returning them safely to Earth, with the ultimate ambition to one day remain there for an extended time,” he wrote.

Advertisement
The Obama administration has been pursuing a visit to Mars for years. But Obama may be overlooking an easier target, if the arguments of one Nasa researcher and numerous supporters are to be believed. While Mars may seem like an attractive destination, we should consider sending people to Venus instead, these people argue.
The planet Venus is seen in the night sky over rocks in the White Desert north of the Farafra Oasis southwest of Cairo. Photo: Reuters
The planet Venus is seen in the night sky over rocks in the White Desert north of the Farafra Oasis southwest of Cairo. Photo: Reuters

Obama’s essay conjures images of Nasa habitats on the red planet as seen in the the film “The Martian.” But that future is a long way off: as the author of “The Martian” has said, it’s far more likely that NASA’s first manned Mars mission will involve humans orbiting a few times and coming back. Even Elon Musk says he’ll be creating a “cargo route” to Mars long before he sends actual people to land there.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x