After Ireland votes for abortion, ‘Yes’ campaigners celebrate but staunch Catholics are left dismayed by anti-church vote
The referendum vote ended a harsh anti-abortion regime enacted in 1983 that required doctors to regard the rights of a fetus, from the moment of conception, as equal to the rights of the mother
Irish Catholics attending Sunday Mass were disappointed with the result of a referendum in which voters opted to legalise abortion and think it reflects the weakening of the church – a situation that was unthinkable in Ireland a generation ago.
There was no mention of the referendum during the sermon at St Mary’s Pro Cathedral, but it was weighing heavily on the minds of some worshippers as they left the Mass in central Dublin.
Ireland voted by a roughly two-to-one margin Friday to end a constitutional ban on abortion, and parliament is expected to approve a more liberal set of laws governing the termination of pregnancies.
Some worshippers said the overwhelming victory of abortion rights activists seeking the repeal of the Eighth Amendment of the constitution reflects a weakening of the Catholic Church’s historic influence and fills them with dread for Ireland’s future.
“I think the ‘yes’ vote was an anti-church vote,” said Annemarie McCarrick, referring to the “yes” vote in favour of ending the constitutional ban.
The 52-year-old lecturer said on the cathedral steps that a series of sex abuse scandals had undermined the influence of the church in Ireland. She said the church had in recent weeks taken a “quiet” stand against repeal, but hadn’t been able to sway people.
“I am religious but the church has definitely lost influence here because of the scandals,” she said. “The people will not take direction from the church any more. It’s hard for the church to have credibility.”
Recent census figures show a small decline in the number of Catholics in Ireland, but it remains by far the dominant religion.
Frank Gaynor, a 75-year-old retiree, said after the Mass that he never imagined the vote in favour of abortion rights would be so lopsided.
He said he was troubled by the way the “yes” campaign used the case of Savita Halappanavar, a 31-year-old dentist who died of sepsis during a prolonged miscarriage after being denied an abortion in Galway in 2012, to drum up support for repeal.
“I was disappointed to see the tragic death of Savita being shamelessly used as an excuse for introducing abortion into a country,” he said. “That was a sepsis issue that was mishandled. Not an Eighth Amendment issue.”
He felt alienated by the campaign: “It’s extraordinary the way the campaign focused so much on ‘me, me, me,’ the rights of the mother, and very little mention of the unborn child. That was sidelined.”
With the vote decided, attention is turning to Ireland’s parliament, which will make new laws to govern abortions.
Waking up, knowing Ireland has come #Together4Yes - there are no words. We did it, for Savita, for Michelle Harte, for Ms Y, Ms P, for all the women and couples and families who we hurt along the way, for the woman we love who needed our Yes, for ourselves. #together4tomorrow pic.twitter.com/mdjxJSB7U1
— Together for Yes (@Together4yes) May 27, 2018
Newspapers reflected on the historic vote. “The power of women,” was the headline on The Sunday Independent, while The Sunday Business Post ran with “Generation Yes” saying Ireland had wrestled with its past and voted to redefine its future.
The Irish Sun on Sunday pictured two women hugging under the headline “No more lonely journeys” in reference to those who had been forced to travel to England to have an abortion.
Writing in The Sunday Times, columnist Una Mullally said: “The fiction of Ireland as a conservative, dogmatically Catholic country has been shattered.
“What happened in the referendum vote was seismic, but more seismic still was the realisation that this vote was reflecting change, not just instigating it.”
The referendum vote ended a harsh anti-abortion regime enacted in 1983 that required doctors to regard the rights of a fetus, from the moment of conception, as equal to the rights of the mother.
In practice, it meant Irish women had to travel abroad for terminations.
The nationwide rejection of the amendment represented a growing tolerance on social issues in the traditionally Roman Catholic country.
Prime Minister Leo Varadkar hailed the vote as bringing a new era to Ireland. He said it will be remembered as “the day Ireland stepped out from under the last of our shadows and into the light. The day we came of age as a country. The day we took our place among the nations of the world.”
His government will propose that abortions be permissible in the first 12 weeks of pregnancy.
It isn’t yet clear what strategy abortion opponents will use in parliament in light of the unexpectedly large vote in favour of repeal. Some opposition figures have indicated they won’t block legislation because they must respect the public will.
The decisive outcome of the landmark referendum was cast as a historic victory for women’s rights. Exit polls indicated that the repeal was endorsed in urban and rural areas alike, with strong support from both men and women.
Backing for repeal was highest among young voters, including many who returned from jobs or universities in continental Europe to vote, but was also high among every age group except those 65 or older.
Since 1983, the Eighth Amendment had forced women seeking to terminate pregnancies to go abroad for abortions, bear children conceived through rape or incest, or take risky illegal measures at home.