‘This is inhumane’: British plan for tougher asylum-seeker rules draws criticism

Home Secretary Priti Patel said the changes are needed to stop illegal people-smuggling rings, and will make the system fairer
But refugee groups and immigration lawyers say it unfairly discriminates against refugees based on the way they got to the UK

Britain

Associated Press

Published: 10:19pm, 24 Mar 2021

Why you can trust SCMP

The British government said on Wednesday it will toughen immigration rules to make it harder for people who arrive by unauthorised routes such as small boats and truck stowaways to be given asylum.

Home Secretary Priti Patel said asylum seekers who come to Britain through organised, sponsored routes, will have their refugee claims considered promptly and will be given support to settle. Those who sneak into the country will only be given temporary permission to stay, will receive limited benefits and will be “regularly reassessed for removal from the UK”.

Patel said the system would be “fair but firm”. “People are dying at sea, in lorries and in shipping containers,” she said. “To stop the deaths we must stop the trade in people that cause them.”

Refugee groups and immigration lawyers say the plan unfairly discriminates against refugees based on the way they got to Britain.

A suspected migrant is escorted by a British border security officer following an incident in the English Channel earlier this year. Photo: DPA

“The proposals effectively create an unfair two-tiered system, whereby someone’s case and the support they receive is judged on how they entered the country and not on their need for protection,” said Mike Adamson, chief executive of the British Red Cross. “This is inhumane.”

But Patel said the changes are needed to stop illegal people-smuggling rings, and will make the system fairer because it will not give an advantage to those who can pay for their passage. “What is inhumane is allowing people to be smuggled through illegal migration, and that is what we want to stop,” she told the BBC. “We will create safe and legal routes to enable people to come to the United Kingdom in a safe way.”

Successive British governments have grappled with the issue of migrants using northern France as a launching point to reach Britain, either by stowing away in trucks or on ferries, or in small boats organised by people smugglers. In 2020, about 8,500 people arrived in Britain by crossing the Channel in small boats, and several died trying to make the journey.

Others have died while being smuggled by truck, including 39 Vietnamese migrants found dead in a refrigerated container in 2019 in the English town of Grays, east of London.

The British and French governments have worked for years to stop the people-smuggling journeys, without much success.

The new British measures – which have not yet been made into legislation and approved by parliament – also include longer sentences for people smugglers and tougher checks to catch adults claiming to be children. The government also promised to speed up asylum decisions and quickly remove those who fail – promises British governments have made and failed to keep for years.

Does British backlash await Hong Kong national security law migrants?

Critics of the government say bureaucratic backlogs left many asylum seekers waiting years for decisions on their status. The coronavirus pandemic has bogged down the system even further.

The British government says 35,099 people made asylum applications in the UK in the year to March 2020. That is about one-third of the number of applicants in Germany and less than half the total for Spain and France.

Britain’s position is also complicated by Brexit. Since leaving the European Union, the UK no longer has a deal with its European neighbours to return people who have sneaked across the Channel.