Lawyers for US soldier who slaughtered 16 Afghan civilians may blame malaria drug
The defence team for US Staff Sergeant Robert Bales, in a hearing scheduled for Tuesday, plans to raise possible use of a controversial malaria drug as justification for a review of the life-without-parole sentence he received for the murder of 16 Afghans.
The US Army Court of Criminal Appeals hearing in Northern Virginia comes four years after Bales was sentenced at Joint Base Lewis-McChord in Western Washington for one of the most notorious US war crimes of recent decades. Early on March 12, 2012, he twice left a small base in southern Afghanistan to kill men, women and children in two Kandahar province villages.
Defence lawyers are expected to argue that while on a 2003-2004 tour in Iraq, and possibly in Afghanistan in 2012, Bales took the anti-malarial drug mefloquine, according to John Henry Browne, a Seattle lawyer who has assisted in the soldier’s defence.
In July 2013, the FDA issued its strictest warning about mefloquine, noting the potential for long-term neurological damage and serious psychiatric side effects. The defence team did not raise Bales’ possible use of the drug during sentencing proceedings the next month.
Defence lawyers now hope the drug issue can persuade a three-judge panel to lessen his sentence. But Bales has never recalled just what malaria medications he took, according to Browne.
A retired Army officer who led the prosecution team said he never saw any documentation in Bales’ medical records that he took mefloquine in Iraq or Afghanistan.
“There is zero evidence that Bales was on mefloquine,” said retired Lieutenant Colonel Jay Morse, who is now in private practice but plans to attend Tuesday’s hearing as an observer.
Appeals are automatic for Army criminal convictions. The three-judge panel has wide-ranging powers to adjust a sentence, or even throw one out.
Bales’ hearing will be held at Fort Belvoir, Virginia.
Defence lawyers have raised another issue in the appeal that involves Afghan witnesses, who flew to the United States to testify against Bales at Joint Base Lewis-McChord. Bales’ lawyers allege that some of those witnesses’ ties to bomb-making were not disclosed, according to Browne.
Bales, 44, was raised in Ohio, and deployed three times to Iraq, then to Afghanistan during more than a decade of Army service at what is now Joint Base Lewis-McChord. His last tour of duty ended as he was taken into custody – wearing a blanket wrapped cape-like around his neck and clad in bloodstained trousers – on the morning he carried out the village attacks.
Pretrial hearings in 2012 featured emotional video testimony from Afghan survivors of the attacks.
In June 2013, Bales pleaded guilty to murder in exchange for the withdrawal of the death penalty.
The next month, The Seattle Times and other publications reported the possibility that Bales might have used mefloquine – information that was based on an FDA “adverse event” notification from an anonymous pharmacist. That report was submitted in 2012 and released by the agency in 2013. It stated that on an unknown date, an anonymous Army patient received the drug – when his health condition contradicted its use – and that he went on to kill 17 Afghans (the initial number of deaths Bales was charged with by the Army.)
But Morse said in an interview Thursday that document was not considered to be evidence of Bales’ use of the drug, and that Browne failed – when ordered by the military court – to offer any other documentation of Bales’ use of the drug. Prosecutors then were able to gain a ruling from the judge that prohibited mefloquine from being brought up during an August hearing that ended in Bales receiving the life sentence.
Later, in an unsuccessful bid for clemency, Bales did not mention possible use of mefloquine. He did cite post-traumatic stress disorder, traumatic brain injury, combat stresses as well as alcohol, sleeping pills and steroids that he took while deployed as possible factors.
“I have come to understand that there isn’t a why, there is only pain,” he wrote from prison in his clemency document.