Moscow’s facial recognition cameras are identifying Navalny supporters: activists
- The Russian capital has one of the world’s most comprehensive surveillance systems
- Rights groups are seeing cases of people brought in for questioning after being picked out by cameras in Moscow for taking part in political rallies
With more than 105,000 cameras, Moscow boasts one of the world’s most comprehensive surveillance systems – which authorities say has helped cut crime and enforce coronavirus lockdown restrictions.
Yet, since the system became fully operational last year, rights activists have noted that cameras have been used to monitor political demonstrations, with a lack of clear rules allowing for abuse of the system.
Russian police detain some 4,400 Navalny supporters at protests
Those concerns were renewed this week, after two straight weekends of nationwide protests.
Alexander Karavaev, a lawyer with Moscow-based human rights group Agora, said that several of his clients were brought in for questioning on January 31 after being picked out by cameras in Moscow.
Among them was Mikhail Shulman, the husband of renowned political scientist Yekaterina Shulman, who was stopped at a metro station after he and his wife approached officers to inquire about transport closures, said the lawyer.
“They (police) explained that the ‘face control’ system installed on the subway cameras had worked,” he said, adding police told him the system was normally used to identify people who have committed a crime.
“To my arguments that the Shulmans were definitely not criminals, they could not answer anything, saying that they were just (doing their job),” the lawyer said.
02:58
Russian police detains thousands of Navalny supporters during protests from Moscow to Vladivostok
Authorities have said that the police’s heavy-handed response to the demonstrations, which saw thousands of arrests across the country, was justified because the protests were illegal and unauthorised.
Anastasiia Zlobina of Human Rights Watch, said that “while the authorities continue to deem peaceful unsanctioned protests illegal, the evolving technology at their disposal will keep facilitating the crackdown against such protests”.
“Using such technology to prosecute peaceful protesters at the opposition rallies violates the freedom of assembly and amounts to a discrimination based on political views,” said the coordinator for Europe and Central Asia.
Moscow’s Department of Technology, which manages the surveillance system, said in an emailed statement it operates in strict accordance with Russian laws and referred questions on the use of cameras to law enforcement agencies.
Moscow’s police did not reply to a request for comment.
Shulman was held for three hours and questioned about the rallies as a witness, before being released with no charges brought against him, Karavaev said.
The case was not isolated, said the lawyer, adding he also represented a 21-year-old woman who was detained after being spotted by cameras at a metro station.
Similar accounts have been shared on social media.
Alexei Navalny ally urges Joe Biden to sanction associates of Putin
Photojournalist Georgy Malets wrote on Facebook last month that he was held at another metro station after receiving a call from police warning him that he had been registered as a “political figure” for taking part in an earlier rally he attended for work.
Earlier this week, TASS news agency quoted a law enforcement source saying facial recognition had been used to detect participants at a rally on January 31 and detain people who took part in earlier unauthorised demonstrations ahead of the event.
Digital rights activists say that current regulations do not clearly define how and when police can access the cameras nor do they establish mechanisms for judicial or public oversight.
“Opaque” rules opened the door for possible rights violations, said Karavaev, adding that the Shulman case suggested cameras were used for purposes that went beyond tackling crime.
02:05
Kremlin critic Alexei Navalny arrested and detained upon return to Russia after near-fatal poisoning
Last year, a Moscow court ruled that the city’s facial recognition system does not violate the privacy of its citizens, dismissing a lawsuit brought by activists seeking to ban the technology’s use at mass events and protests.
The case is now with the European Court of Human Rights.
“Collection and storage of protesters’ unique biometric data in itself raises serious privacy concerns,” said Zlobina.
