Donald Trump’s shock deal with Democrats reveals rift with top Republicans – particularly House speaker Paul Ryan
The moment distilled the inherent tensions between Trump, an ideologically flexible dealmaker, and Ryan, a loyal Republican whose discomfort with Trump led him to withhold his endorsement
It started out cold as ice, and then turned warm and friendly. Now the tortured relationship between US President Donald Trump and House Speaker Paul Ryan has gone cool again, with the Republican president making clear he has no qualms about bucking the Republican leader to cut deals with his Democratic foes.
The two men dined at the White House on Thursday night and discussed legislative challenges ahead for the fall, a get-together that was scheduled over Congress’ August recess, long before the head-spinning events of this week. In a moment that stunned Washington, Trump cut a debt and disaster aid deal Wednesday with Congress’ Democratic leaders as Ryan and Senate majority leader Mitch McConnell watched on helplessly, after lobbying unsuccessfully for much different terms.
“We all thought we had more time, obviously, to deal with the debt-limit issue, and that’s before the hurricanes hit,” Ryan said on Thursday. “So the president made a game call yesterday that he thought it is in our country’s interest to have bipartisan support in a bipartisan package to deal with these ongoing hurricane disasters.”
The moment distilled the inherent tensions between Trump, 71, a former Democrat and ideologically flexible dealmaker, and Ryan, 47, a loyal Republican whose discomfort with Trump led him to withhold his endorsement for weeks last year.
After Trump was elected the two papered over their differences and even developed a rapport, talking frequently during health care negotiations earlier this year, as each understood they needed the other to advance individual and shared goals. But their phone calls have tapered off of late and Trump has expressed his frustration with Republican leaders on multiple fronts, culminating in the president’s decision to ditch them and join hands with the Democrats instead.
Trump exulted in his newly bipartisan approach on Thursday, declaring it “a great thing for our country” while Ryan mostly grinned and bore it.
At the Capitol on Wednesday, Ryan had deemed a three-month debt ceiling increase as “unworkable” and “ridiculous”. Yet an hour later, Trump overruled his strong objections to side with the Democrats.
The president’s rebuff on the debt came just days after Trump ignored Ryan’s pleas not to end the programme to aid immigrants brought to the country as children and living here illegally. Instead, Trump ended the programme and tossed the issue to Congress to resolve in six months.
A spokeswoman for Ryan, AshLee Strong, said on Friday the speaker and Trump “have a good relationship and are in frequent communication as the two work to advance the legislative priorities Republicans promised, including tax reform. In fact, they talked five times this week,” including the dinner.
The House on Friday passed the US$15 billion in disaster aid and a three-month government funding extension, sending it to Trumph he promptly signed.
Trump’s deal “shows that the president wants to move the ball forward, and that’s not always going to be by agreeing with Republican leadership,” said Jim Renacci, an Ohio Republican.
Trump echoed that sentiment in a tweet Friday, showing his frustration with the GOP’s failed attempt to overhaul Obamacare. “Republicans, sorry, but I’ve been hearing about Repeal & Replace for 7 years, didn’t happen!” he wrote.
Indeed for Ryan, Republican reactions to the deal exposed some lurking threats to his perch atop a conference where unrest brews nearly ceaselessly among conservatives, and there have been recent rumblings of a possible coup.
Trump remains highly popular in the conservative districts occupied by many House Republicans, much more so than Ryan himself, who is scorned by many in the Republican base as an establishment sell-out. In a whipsawed moment, some House Republicans defended Trump’s handling of a deal they don’t like, while simultaneously criticising Ryan, who had been overruled by the president. It also underscored the political pressure on Ryan to try to remain in the president’s good graces even when Trump is flirting with Democrats.
Congressman Steve King said the message in his conservative district is that “congressional Republicans need to get behind the president”. That sentiment “makes him weaker,” King said of Ryan.
Congressman Paul Gosar of Arizona described Ryan as “very unpopular” in his district, while regard for Trump is “pretty high”.
As far as his constituents are concerned, Gosar said, they’d be happy if Ryan got the boot and Trump stayed, saying: “That’s kind of the mantra in my district.”
Republicans, sorry, but I've been hearing about Repeal & Replace for 7 years, didn't happen! Even worse, the Senate Filibuster Rule will....
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) September 8, 2017
...never allow the Republicans to pass even great legislation. 8 Dems control - will rarely get 60 (vs. 51) votes. It is a Repub Death Wish!
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) September 8, 2017
For his part, Trump has soured on the Republican congressional leadership in recent months, fuming to associates that they led him astray on their health care strategy, among other complaints.
The president has told those close to him that he regrets choosing to tackle the repeal and replace of Barack Obama’s health care law as his first legislative push. He has singled out Ryan for blame, saying the speaker assured him it would pass and instead handed him an early, humiliating failure, before ultimate House passage of a revived bill, according to three White House and outside advisers familiar with the conversations but not authorised to speak about them publicly. Republican Party health care efforts collapsed in the Senate in July.
Trump has spoken to Ryan less frequently in recent weeks, particularly after the departure of his first chief of staff, Reince Priebus, who has deep Wisconsin ties to the speaker. Priebus would sometimes broker the calls and stress to each man their importance, according to two people familiar with the conversations. Those calls have occurred less often since John Kelly took over as chief of staff.
Though Trump has expressed particular anger at McConnell for the failed Senate health care vote and for not protecting him from the Russia investigation, he grudgingly has told associates that he is aware of the Senate leader’s grip on power. He has spoken less glowingly about Ryan’s own ability to lead due to the shorter House terms and the growing insurgency within the conservative Freedom Caucus.
Ryan’s position is seen as secure for now, if only because it is widely accepted that no other House Republican could garner the support needed to replace him. But even allies believe his tenure in the job could be finite, and might depend in part on the whims of a president with whom he has no real deep ties.
“I think any speaker is going to have a very difficult time in this environment,” said Congressman Tom Reed. “The nature of that job, I think, over time, they don’t last.”
Additional reporting by Bloomberg