Breastfeeding row: Trump says poor mothers need milk formula, but experts don’t swallow it
Trump says impoverished women should not be denied access to formula – a US$47 billion industry – after US is accused of trying to sink UN resolution on breastfeeding
US President Donald Trump weighed in Monday to defend women’s “access” to formula milk, after an article accused the United States of seeking to torpedo a World Health Organisation resolution on breastfeeding.
A weekend report in The New York Times stated that US delegates to a recent WHO meeting sought to delete from a resolution on infant nutrition language that urged member states to “protect, promote and support” breastfeeding.
The United States reportedly pressured Ecuador to drop sponsorship of the text, threatening trade sanctions and military aid cuts. In the end, the Times said, the Russians stepped in to introduce the measure – and the final resolution preserved most of the original wording.
Noting that the US position aligned with infant formula manufacturers, the paper cited the case as an example of the Trump administration siding with corporate interests on public health and environmental issues.
The failing NY Times Fake News story today about breast feeding must be called out. The U.S. strongly supports breast feeding but we don’t believe women should be denied access to formula. Many women need this option because of malnutrition and poverty.
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) July 9, 2018
Trump hit out at the Times article, while saying the United States was committed to ensuring women are not “denied” formula.
“The failing NY Times Fake News story today about breast feeding must be called out,” the president tweeted.
“The US strongly supports breast feeding but we don’t believe women should be denied access to formula. Many women need this option because of malnutrition and poverty.”
Health experts said the president’s stance suggested a lack of knowledge about the issues.
“Malnutrition and poverty are the precise settings where you absolutely do need to breastfeed, because that’s the setting where access to safe and clean water for reconstituting powdered formula is often impossible to find,” Dr Michele Barry, director of the Centre for Innovation in Global Health in the Stanford School of Medicine, told The New York Times in response to Trump’s tweet.
The State Department meanwhile described as “false” the notion that Washington had threatened a partner country.
“The United States believed the resolution as originally drafted called on states to erect hurdles for mothers seeking to provide nutrition to their children,” said a State Department official.
“We recognise not all women are able to breastfeed for a variety of reasons,” it added, saying they should have “full information about safe alternatives.”
Ecuador’s Health Minister Veronica Espinosa said her country had fought for passage of the resolution and “did not give in to private or commercial interests, or any other form of pressure.”
The WHO has long advocated exclusive breastfeeding until six months of age, and partial breastfeeding for up to two years or more.
But baby milk formula represents a huge global market – worth US$47 billion in 2015, according to Euromonitor International – dominated by a handful of groups, several of them American, with emerging markets accounting for most current growth.