Trump-Russia collusion investigations

At Paul Manafort trial, Rick Gates says he assisted in filing false tax returns

A courtroom showdown begins between two business associates who once worked closely together and played important roles in US President Donald Trump’s election

PUBLISHED : Tuesday, 07 August, 2018, 5:33am
UPDATED : Tuesday, 07 August, 2018, 7:00am

Rick Gates, a former campaign aide to US President Donald Trump, testified on Monday at his former business partner Paul Manafort’s tax and bank fraud trial that he assisted Manafort in filing false tax returns.

Gates, who is cooperating with prosecutors in the trial of Trump’s former campaign chairman, testified that Manafort directed him to report overseas income as loans to lower his taxable income.

Gates’ testimony began a courtroom showdown between two business associates who once worked closely together and played important roles in Trump’s election bid.

Gates has been regarded as a crucial witness for the government after pleading guilty earlier this year to two felony charges and agreeing to cooperate in special counsel Robert Mueller’s investigation into possible ties between Russia and the Trump campaign.

Gates testified on Monday that he stole money from Manafort, and also said that Manafort had asked him to omit information in a court deposition regarding a private equity fund.

Gates testified that under sentencing guidelines he could face 57 to 71 months in prison for his crimes.

Manafort’s defence has sought to blame Gates, described by witnesses as his “right-hand man,” for any illegal conduct and accused him of embezzling millions of dollars from Manafort.

Gates, who also served in a senior role in Trump’s campaign, is expected to face aggressive cross-examination once prosecutors are finished questioning him.

The trial opened last week with a display of Manafort’s opulent lifestyle, then progressed into testimony about what prosecutors say were years of financial deception.

In calling Gates, the government will present jurors with the first-hand account of a co-conspirator expected to say Manafort was knee-deep in an alleged scheme to hide millions of dollars from the IRS and defraud several banks.

During the questioning, US District Judge TS Ellis III will be both referee and wild card.

He has played those roles throughout the trial, repeatedly scolding prosecutors to rein in their depictions of Manafort’s lavish lifestyle and demanding that they “move it along.” It is not a crime, he has said several times, to be rich and to spend ostentatiously.

Nonetheless, jurors were told of more than US$900,000 in expensive suits, a US$15,000 ostrich jacket and lavish properties replete with expensive audio and video systems, a tennis court encircled by hundreds of flowers and, as one witness put it, “one of the bigger ponds in the Hamptons.”

One by one, a retired carpenter, a natty clothier and a high-end landscaper detailed how Manafort paid them in international wire transfers from offshore companies.

Prosecutors say Manafort used those companies to stash millions of dollars from his Ukrainian consulting work, proceeds he omitted year after year from his income tax returns.

Later, they say, when that income dwindled, Manafort launched a different scheme, shoring up his struggling finances by using doctored documents to obtain millions more in bank loans.

On Friday, an accountant and tax preparer, Cindy Laporta, admitted that she helped disguise $900,000 in foreign income as a loan to reduce Manafort’s tax burden.

Laporta, who testified under an immunity deal with the government, acknowledged that she agreed under pressure from Gates to alter a tax document for one of Manafort’s businesses.

Under cross-examination, she said at the time she believed Manafort was directing Gates’ actions and “knew what was going on.”

All told, prosecutors allege that Manafort failed to report a “significant percentage” of the more than US$60 million they say he received from Ukrainian oligarchs.

They sought to show jurors how that money flowed from more than a dozen shell companies used to stash the income in Cyprus.

Though the names of those companies appeared on wire transfers and at times on his book-keeper’s ledger, both Manafort’s accountants and his book-keeper say they never knew that the companies – and corresponding offshore bank accounts – were controlled by Manafort.

When they appeared, the book-keeper and accountants said, they thought the companies were clients or, in some cases, lenders.

But defence lawyers are trying to convince the jury that Manafort was consumed by his consulting business and left the particulars of his finances to professionals and, in particular, to Gates.