From no symptoms to sudden death: immune system holds clues to wide range of coronavirus outcomes
- In some patients – mostly men – body goes rogue and attacks own defences instead of fighting Covid-19
- Children may fare better than adults thanks to robust ‘first responder’ immune cells that wane with age
One of Covid-19’s scariest mysteries is why some people are mildly ill or have no symptoms and others rapidly die – and scientists are starting to unravel why.
An international team of researchers found that in some people with severe Covid-19, the body goes rogue and attacks one of its own key immune defences instead of fighting the coronavirus. Most were men, helping to explain why the virus is hitting men harder than women.
And separate research suggests that children fare better than adults thanks to robust “first responder” immune cells that wane with age.
They are the latest in a list of studies uncovering multiple features of the immune system’s intricate cascade that can tip the scales between a good or bad outcome. Next up: figuring out if all these new clues might offer much-needed ways to intervene.
02:01
China’s Wuhan moves on as global coronavirus death toll passes 1 million
“We have the knowledge and capability of really boosting many aspects of the immune system. But we need to not use the sledge hammer,” cautioned Dr Betsy Herold of New York’s Albert Einstein College of Medicine, who co-authored the child study.
Adding to the complexity, people’s wildly varying reactions also reflect other factors, such as how healthy they were to begin with and how much of the virus – the “dose” – they were exposed to.
“Infection and what happens after infection is a very dynamic thing,” said Alessandro Sette, a researcher at the La Jolla Institute for Immunology in San Diego, who is studying yet another piece of the immune response.
There are two main arms of the immune system. Innate immunity is the body’s first line of defence. As soon as the body detects a foreign intruder, key molecules, such as interferons and inflammation-causing cytokines, launch a wide-ranging attack.
Innate immune cells also alert the slower-acting “adaptive” arm of the immune system, the germ-specific sharpshooters, to gear up. B cells start producing virus-fighting antibodies, the proteins getting so much attention in the vaccine hunt.
Scientists uncover why many Covid-19 patients lose sense of smell and taste
But antibodies are not the whole story. Adaptive immunity’s many other ingredients include “killer” T cells that destroy virus-infected cells – and “memory” T and B cells that remember an infection so they spring into action quicker if they encounter that germ again.
Usually when a virus invades a cell, proteins called Type I interferons spring into action, defending the cell by interfering with viral growth. But new research shows those crucial molecules were essentially absent in a subset of people with severe Covid-19.
An international project uncovered two reasons. In blood from nearly 1,000 severe Covid-19 patients, researchers found one in 10 had what are called autoantibodies – antibodies that mistakenly attack those needed virus fighters. Especially surprising, autoimmune disorders tend to be more common in women – but 95 per cent of these Covid-19 patients were men.
The researchers did not find the damaging molecules in patients with mild or asymptomatic Covid-19.
02:40
If China’s coronavirus vaccines work, which countries will get them and for how much?
In another 660 severely ill patients, the same team found 3.5 per cent had gene mutations that did not produce Type I interferons.
Each of those silent vulnerabilities was enough to tip the balance in favour of the virus early on, said Dr. Jean-Laurent Casanova, an infectious disease geneticist at Rockefeller University in New York, who co-leads the Covid Human Genetic Effort. He is paid by the Howard Hughes Medical Institute, which also helps fund the Associated Press Health and Science Department.
Certain interferons are used as medicines and are under study as a possible Covid-19 treatment; the autoantibody discovery adds another factor to consider.
It is not clear why children appear less at risk from Covid-19. But occasionally they are sick enough for hospitalisation, giving Herold’s team the opportunity to compare 60 adults and 65 children and teens at New York’s Montefiore Health System.
The children produced much higher levels of certain cytokines that are among the innate immune system’s first responders. When the immune system’s next stage kicked in, both adults and children made antibodies targeting the coronavirus. Here’s the rub: the adults’ adaptive immune response was more the type that can trigger an inflammatory overreaction.
Vaccines alone won’t be enough to fight Covid-19, Novartis CEO says
The findings suggest children‘s’ early robust reaction lets their immune system get ahead of the virus, making an overreaction less likely “and that’s protecting them”, Herold said.
The coronavirus that causes Covid-19 is new to humans. But Sette’s team studied blood samples that were stored in freezers before the pandemic and found some harboured memory T cells that recognised a tiny portion of the new virus in laboratory tests.
“You can actually tell that this is an experienced T cell. This has seen combat before,” Sette said. Researchers in Germany, Britain and other countries have made similar findings.
The new coronavirus has cousins that cause as many as 30 per cent of common colds, so researchers believe those T cells could be remnants from past colds.
But despite the speculation, “we don’t know yet” that having those T cells makes any difference in who gets seriously sick with Covid-19, noted Rory de Vries, co-author of a study in the Netherlands that also found such T cells in old blood.
All these findings beg for a deeper understanding of the myriad ways some people can be more susceptible than others.
“We need to look quite broadly and not jump into premature conclusions about any one particular facet of the immune system,” said Stanford University immunologist Bali Pulendran. He also has found some innate immune cells “in a state of hibernation” in seriously ill adults and next is looking for differences before and after people get sick.
But, “it’s not just all about the immune system”, cautioned Dr. Anita McElroy, a viral immunity expert at the University of Pittsburgh who is closely watching the research. A way to tell in advance who’s most at risk? “We’re a long, long way from that.”
