-
Advertisement
Hong Kong environmental issues
Opinion
SCMP Editorial

Editorial | Hong Kong’s slope safety monitoring must keep pace with climate change

While the risk of casualties from slope failure has not been high, the city mustn’t be complacent amid reports of repeated landslides

Reading Time:2 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Workers respond to a landslide in Shau Kei Wan, cleaning up mud and boulders on October 19, 2023. Photo: Elson Li
Slope safety monitoring is rightly under scrutiny after an investigation by the Hong Kong ombudsman turned up an alarming number of landslides. The city must redouble efforts to reclaim its reputation for good management of such sites after several government-managed slopes were found to have repeatedly failed in recent years.

The Office of the Ombudsman released a report on January 8, based on its review of nine serious landslides at man-made slopes since 2008. Four incidents happened along Wing Lung Road in the New Territories over the past five years, despite the area being on an official monitoring list.

Ombudsman Jack Chan Jick-chi’s office focused on landslide prevention work and management of man-made slopes maintained by the authorities. Even when emergency work was carried out after a first incident, “potential landslide risks” were “not necessarily” fully mitigated. Most slopes with repeated landslides were either not included in a specific monitoring programme or considered relatively low priority. The report also said some sites had “repeated landslides” within three years of an initial incident. A spokesman for the ombudsman’s office said recurrences raised concerns about the “potential risks and structural safety of these slopes”.

Advertisement
The results suggest an erosion of Hong Kong’s reputation as a world leader in slope engineering. The safety infrastructure was put in place after deadly landslides in the 1970s at Sau Mau Ping and Po Shan Road. But yesterday’s engineering standards are being tested by climate reality today.

Global warming has fuelled increasingly unpredictable and ferocious rainstorms which have set records for precipitation and duration. Slope registration, monitoring systems and stabilisation works must evolve quickly to stay ahead of evolving weather patterns.

Advertisement

While landslides in recent years have not involved major casualties, there must not be complacency among site managers. It is a good start that relevant government departments have already accepted the Ombudsman’s 32 recommendations. In a city where more than 60 per cent of the land has natural hillsides, there is precious little margin for error.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x