My Take | Man vs machine: we are a long way from real artificial intelligence

  • Before you buy into the ChatGPT hype, perhaps you should first listen to the criticism of current AI by some eminent philosophers

A smartphone with a displayed ChatGPT logo is placed on a computer motherboard in this illustration taken February 23, 2023. Photo: Reuters

Do philosophers ever have anything to offer investors? I know it’s a strange question, but when it comes to artificial intelligence (AI), it turns out that those who work under the intellectual umbrella of cognitive science, linguistics and philosophy of language have a lot to say. For shorthand here, I will refer to such researchers simply as “philosophers”. One reason is that the towering intellectual figure Noam Chomsky, whom I will discuss below, has revolutionised all three disciplines.

Hot new tech has a tendency to blow bubbles among investors. It’s primed for hype and speculation. Its promoters usually overpromise and underdeliver, even if the underlying innovation eventually pans out such as the internet and e-commerce, but not before the dotcom bubble and its spectacular bursting. Often, though, they don’t even deliver. Cryptocurrencies, anyone?

Print option is available for subscribers only.
SUBSCRIBE NOW
Copyright © 2025 South China Morning Post Publishers Ltd. All rights reserved.