Source:
https://scmp.com/comment/insight-opinion/article/2113627/why-donald-trumps-insults-may-back-kim-jong-un-nuclear-armed
Opinion/ Comment

Why Donald Trump’s insults may back Kim Jong-un into a nuclear-armed corner

Robert Delaney says the US president’s knack for shocking rhetoric worked better than expected in domestic politics, but his comments about the North Korean leader have crossed a dangerous line

Donald Trump takes part in a ceremony to present the Presidents Cup to the US team at the Liberty National Golf Club in Jersey City, New Jersey, on Sunday. Photo: AP

US President Donald Trump has proven to the established political class that shocking rhetoric now works like a gun in a knife fight.

Many in Washington thought Trump’s calling Mexicans rapists and commenting on Rosie O’Donnell’s “fat, ugly” face would derail his political momentum. Instead, these comments and many others helped usher him into the White House.

But the strategy that has worked well in many of Trump’s political skirmishes crosses a line from crude and coldly calculating to flagrantly irresponsible when used against North Korea’s Kim Jong-un.

It is one thing to chastise demonstrators facing down white supremacists and denigrate women with references to blood. Such derogatory comments horrify Americans outside of Trump’s base and establish new lows for US politicians, but they don’t carry the possibility of grave consequences for the rest of the world.

In repeatedly calling Kim “Rocket Man” and using other language to demean him, Trump has brought his schoolyard bully tactics into a conflict that has global thermonuclear war as one of several possible outcomes if cooler heads don’t prevail.

North Korean leader Kim Jong-un visits a farm run by the Korean People’s Army at an undisclosed location, in this undated photo released from North Korea's official Korean Central News Agency on Friday. Photo: AFP
North Korean leader Kim Jong-un visits a farm run by the Korean People’s Army at an undisclosed location, in this undated photo released from North Korea's official Korean Central News Agency on Friday. Photo: AFP

On a more immediate level, Trump has undermined a diplomatic effort that accomplished what successive US administrations never managed: China’s cooperation, which is essential for any effort to subdue Pyongyang without resorting to military action.

US Ambassador to the United Nations Nikki Haley has done an excellent job in working with her Chinese counterpart Liu Jieyi. Bargaining with Liu, Haley managed to get two sets of North Korea sanctions unanimously passed in the Security Council.

Secretary of State Rex Tillerson and Defence Secretary James Mattis have also struck a sensible balance between cooperation and standing firm on non-negotiables such as the US’ missile defence deployment in South Korea.

US Ambassador to the United Nations Nikki Haley speaks to UN Chinese Ambassador Liu Jieyi before a Security Council meeting at the UN headquarters in New York on September 4. Photo: EPA-EFE
US Ambassador to the United Nations Nikki Haley speaks to UN Chinese Ambassador Liu Jieyi before a Security Council meeting at the UN headquarters in New York on September 4. Photo: EPA-EFE

In Beijing this past weekend, Tillerson said the US currently has “lines of communication to Pyongyang”, which was an encouraging revelation given the heightened tensions around the Korean peninsula.

However, none of these diplomatic efforts mean anything if Washington’s only objective is a complete shutdown of Pyongyang’s nuclear weapons capability, because Trump’s taunts cement Kim’s resolve to follow through regardless of the sticks and carrots the US and China wield.

Sue Mi Terry, who served as a senior North Korea analyst in the CIA under former president George W. Bush, said on the sidelines of a Korea Society event in New York last week that Trump’s decision to lob insults directly at Kim has pushed the stand-off to “a crisis point”. The insults, she said, made it politically impossible for Kim to heed calls to halt his nuclear weapons programme.

US Secretary of State Rex Tillerson walks by Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi before a meeting at the Great Hall of the People in Beijing on Friday. Tillerson has said lines of communication between the US and North Korea are open, though President Donald Trump has called such communications a “waste of time”. Photo: Reuters
US Secretary of State Rex Tillerson walks by Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi before a meeting at the Great Hall of the People in Beijing on Friday. Tillerson has said lines of communication between the US and North Korea are open, though President Donald Trump has called such communications a “waste of time”. Photo: Reuters

State Department spokeswoman Heather Nauert said in Washington, after Tillerson’s hopeful comments, that “North Korean officials have shown no indication that they are interested or ready for talks regarding denuclearisation”.

Then, as though he wanted to close off any possibility that Pyongyang would respond to Washington’s overtures, Trump poured cold water all over Tillerson’s efforts by calling them “a waste of time” and referring to Kim as “Little Rocket Man”.

There is no way to know if Pyongyang would pick up the phone were it not for Trump’s insults. We can be sure, however, that they do not help.

We also know that Trump’s need to fling insults outweighs any concern he has for the gravity of possible outcomes.

Robert Delaney is a US correspondent for the Post based in New York