The wreck of the HMS Erebus found in the Canadian Arctic in 2014. Photo: Reuters/Parks Canada/Handout
Source:
https://scmp.com/culture/books/article/2085765/when-cultures-collide-epic-story-franklins-lost-arctic-expedition-and Books
When cultures collide: the epic story of Franklin’s lost Arctic expedition and how Inuit lore led to Erebus and Terror shipwrecks
Paul Watson’s three-part book about the British explorer’s doomed search for fabled Northwest Passage and efforts to find his vessels Erebus and Terror comes alive in retelling of a native Inuk’s part in wrecks’ recent discovery
A painting depicting The Erebus and HMS Terror stuck in the Arctic ice.
by Paul Watson
W. W. Norton & Co
4/5 stars
In 1845, Britain’s Sir John Franklin set out with two ships and 128 men to seek an open trade route through the Arctic to the Pacific – and disappeared.
Not until 2014 and 2016 were the Terror and Erebus finally discovered, sitting upright on the ocean floor, the culmination of decades of work by dozens of searchers.
Paul Watson, a Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist, tells how Inuit lore, British pride and modern technology often worked at cross purposes, and also how people, sometimes for no logical reason, became obsessed with the ill-fated expedition.
Ice Ghosts is in three parts: the expedition, the initial search and the modern-day attempts. Drawing only from historic documents for parts one and two, Watson’s account is as exhaustively detailed as one would expect from an ace reporter but also, understandably, a little lifeless.
Franklin was desperate to repair a tarnished reputation when he persuaded the Royal Navy to let him lead a third attempt to discover the lucrative trade route.
The helm of HMS Terror, whose last resting place beneath the waters of the Canadian Arctic was found in 2016. Photo: The Guardian/Arctic Research Foundation
When the ships failed to return, Lady Franklin was relentless in demanding and often funding search expeditions. But bad luck, a dismissiveness of Inuit accounts and the vastness of the Arctic led to failure. With Lady Franklin’s death in 1875, it appeared that the mystery would remain.
The search and Watson’s writing are reinvigorated in part three. A deeper message is revealed in Watson’s long relationship with an Inuk named Louis Kamookak.
Painting of Erebus and Terror in the Arctic
Sir John Franklin
As Kamookak listened, he became convinced that native people knew what had happened to the ships. His work was patient, exhaustive – and discounted by the outside world.
Later searchers brought technology to the hunt, and indeed, the ultimate discoveries were a result of scientific advances (as well as some hardy scuba divers). Yet mysteries remain. What exactly caused the ships’ demise? Was there mutiny or heroism? The debates continue.
But the ships’ locations vindicated what Kamookak had learned from the elders. Watson’s deeply felt understanding of that work heightens Kamookak’s sad satisfaction while enacting, at book’s end, an ancient rite over the sunken Erebus.
Ice Ghosts documents what happens when cultures collide. Or perhaps more pointedly, when one culture feels superior for no better reason than pride.