Source:
https://scmp.com/magazines/style/celebrity/article/3125184/end-british-royal-family-experts-say-firm-safe-now-meghan Celebrities
The end of the British royal family? Experts say ‘The Firm’ is safe for now, but Meghan and Harry’s Oprah interview signals trouble ahead
- UK opinion polls show just 22 per cent of people sympathise with Meghan and Harry’s plight, but only 17 per cent think the country should ditch the monarchy
- Queen Elizabeth may be beloved but ‘King Charles’ likely won’t be, warn experts, saying abolition would still require constitutional change or a referendum
epa07699341 A handout photo made available by the Duke and Duchess of Sussex shows the official christening photograph with Prince Harry and Meghan, Duke and Duchess of Sussex (front, C) with their son, Archie and (L-R) Camilla, Duchess of Cornwall, Prince Charles, Prince of Wales, Doria Ragland, Lady Jane Fellowes, Lady Sarah McCorquodale, Prince William, Duke of Cambridge and Catherine, Duchess of Cambridge in the Green Drawing Room at Windsor Castle, in Windsor, Britain, 06 July 2019. NEWS EDITORIAL USE ONLY. NO COMMERICAL USE. NO MERCHANDISING, ADVERTISING, SOUVENIRS, MEMORABILIA or COLOURABLY SIMILAR. NOT FOR USE AFTER AFTER 31 DECEMBER, 2019 WITHOUT PRIOR PERMISSION FROM ROYAL COMMUNICATIONS. NO CROPPING. Copyright in this photograph is vested in The Duke and Duchess of Sussex. Publications are asked to credit the photographs to Chris Allerton. No charge should be made for the supply, release or publication of the photograph. The photograph must not be digitally enhanced,…
The British monarchy’s immediate survival is assured, despite Prince Harry and his wife Meghan Markle’s claims of racism, experts say, but cultural rifts exposed by the row could signal trouble ahead.
The revelations are a “soft-power disaster for Britain” that raise questions over whether the monarchy “can, or should, survive at all without the queen at its head”, according to The Times’ diplomatic correspondent, Catherine Philp.
But polling at home suggests the couple’s explosive interview with US chat show host Oprah Winfrey has so far had little impact on the popularity of the 1,000-year-old institution.
Prince Harry and Meghan Markle spilled a lot more than many bargained for in their interview with Oprah Winfrey. Photo: TNS
Around a third of people told YouGov that their sympathies lie mostly with the royal family, while only 22 per cent said they had more sympathy for Harry and Meghan – a four point rise since the interview was aired in Britain on Monday.
“This is certainly a crisis for the family, but that’s the royal family as a soap opera. It’s not a crisis for the institution of the monarchy,” said Robert Hazell, professor of government and the constitution at University College London. “It would only become a crisis for the institution if opinion polls began to show that it had significantly reduced support for the monarchy.”
Britain’s Queen Elizabeth remains much loved by many in the UK, but can the rest of her family maintain the decorum she is known for. Photo: AFP
Queen Elizabeth, who has been on the throne since 1952 and is now 94, remains hugely popular, with a 79-per cent approval rating that politicians can only dream of.
An Ipsos Mori poll this week also indicated that only 17 per cent of people believed the country would be better off without a monarchy.
But the family is reeling after a year in which Harry and Meghan quit the royal family and questions swirled about Prince Andrew, the queen’s second oldest son.
The results of the Ipsos Mori poll on the future of the British Monarchy. Photo: @RoyalCentral/ Twitter
He caused anger by giving a disastrous television interview defending his relationship with the convicted US sex offender Jeffrey Epstein, and denying claims that he had sex with a 17-year-old girl trafficked by the disgraced financier.
A closer look at the polling also reveals a much less favourable opinion of the queen’s oldest son and heir Prince Charles, 72, and a sharp contrast in the attitudes between younger and older generations.
“The Queen still draws multigenerational, global admiration. Prince Charles, however, very much less so,” wrote The Times’ Philp.
The official christening photograph of Prince Harry and Meghan, Duke and Duchess of Sussex, with their son, Archie in July 2019. It’s since been revealed that someone in the family was apprehensive about ‘how dark’ the child’s skin tone would be. Photo: EPA-EFE
“Charles is the named member of the royal family who perhaps emerges worst from the (Harry and Meghan) interview, potentially a far greater problem for the monarchy than the characterisation of an anonymised, uncaring ‘Firm’ that Harry suggested even the queen was at the mercy of.
“The generational divisions also bode ill for Britain’s image overseas, with the under-40s far more supportive of Harry and Meghan’s version of events than their elders.”
The charges of racism against an unnamed senior royal particularly resonate with Britain’s younger generation, which has grown up in an increasingly diverse country.
Only 29 per cent of the 18-34-year-olds polled by Ipsos Mori said Britain would be worse off if the monarchy was abolished.
A total of 45 per cent said it would make no difference, and 19 per cent said it would make the country better.
“When the queen dies, the difference that Prince Charles faces is that he will be a very elderly monarch. He will be nothing like the young Queen Elizabeth in 1952,” said Hazell.
“It is quite likely the tabloid press will run opinion polls saying, do you want Prince Charles as king or do you want that young and attractive Prince William? I think that will be difficult for the monarchy.”
But he added that younger people had historically tended towards republicanism, before becoming more sympathetic as they grew older.
While republicans sense an opportunity as the queen’s long reign draws to a close, they still face daunting obstacles in bringing down an institution that has weathered centuries of scandal, intrigue and plots, and is an integral part of British cultural life.
“They would have to change the constitution,” said Hazell. “Although this isn’t written … all commentators have accepted that such a significant change would require a referendum.”
Britain’s Prince William will succeed his father, Prince Charles, to the throne eventually – but would many prefer him to ascend first? Photo: PA
Britain has endured five torrid years of division and constitutional wrangling since deciding to leave the European Union in a 2016 referendum.
Neither of the main political parties has shown any enthusiasm for another seismic vote. And even if Charles proves unpopular, “that’s not a threat to the monarchy as an institution, it’s a threat to Charles as king,” added Hazell, with the more popular Prince William, his eldest son, 39, waiting in the wings.