Delayed gratification: The curious case of a club’s 30-year court struggle to be declared champions
Sport Recife finally named 1987 Brazil league champions as win over Rio de Janeiro giants Flamengo is confirmed by ruling panel
After 30 years, Brazil’s Supreme Court finally decided on Tuesday the winners of the 1987 league title.
It’s Sport Recife, a team that more often fight against relegation than for titles. The northeastern club beat Rio de Janeiro giants Flamengo 3-1 in the ruling by a five-member panel.
One member of the panel abstained because his son had worked as a Flamengo attorney in the case.
The long-running dispute began when Flamengo won the title in a league created by the clubs involved. However, Brazil’s football confederation decided to organise a separate competition, which was won by Sport. The confederation then tried to get Flamengo to play Sport in a final, an offer that the Rio giants rejected.
Had the panel failed to decide, the case would have gone to the full 11-member Supreme Court.
“Football is passion, but the ideal is that sporting decisions do not come to court,” Justice Rosa Maria Weber said.
Brazil’s Supreme Court is clogged with dozens of investigations into public officials in a sprawling corruption scandal involving state-run oil company Petrobras and major conglomerate Odebrecht, among others.
Judge Marco Aurelio Mello, a Flamengo fan that ruled against his club, said there will be no more appeals in the affair. “This will be the final score,” Mello said during the session.
Also a Flamengo fan, Justice Luis Roberto Barroso said “there is no place worse than the judicial system to discuss sports”. He voted to split the title between the two clubs.
After the decision, Barroso said “40 million fans have their hearts shattered”.
“And that includes me,” Mello said.
Flamengo, the most popular team in Brazil, have always claimed the title and are unlikely to be swayed by the high-court ruling. But seconds after the decision, Sport Recife proudly announced the title on their website.
“[The title of] 87 is, undoubtedly, ours,” Sport Recife said. “In court, once more, Sport beat those who ran away.”
Flamengo used Twitter to answer Sport’s comment. “On the pitch, on the ball, always Flamengo. Brazilian champion of 1987.”
Brazil’s football confederation did not comment on the ruling.