Advertisement
Advertisement
LeBron James’ inability to criticise anything related to the China pokes holes in his assertion that he speaks for “social justice” issues all over the world. Photo credit: Kirby Lee-USA TODAY Sports
Opinion
Patrick Blennerhassett
Patrick Blennerhassett

LeBron James’ void on Hong Kong and China while claiming to speak up for social justice brings motives into question

  • The Los Angeles Lakers star actively sought to put down Daryl Morey when Houston Rockets GM commented on Hong Kong
  • James says he speaks from ‘a very educated mind’ but has contradicted himself in the past
In the fall of 2019 as Hong Kong’s anti-government protests crippled the city, locals took to Southorn Playground in Wan Chai to burn LeBron James jerseys.

James had found himself entangled in the NBA’s controversy with the Chinese Communist Party, a long-lasting row that kicked off that October when then Houston Rockets general manager Daryl Morey tweeted his support for Hong Kong’s protesters.

The Los Angeles Lakers star, who was in China for two preseason games against the Brooklyn Nets, made his way back to the US and laid into Morey during an interview.

“I don’t want to get into a feud with Daryl but I believe he wasn’t educated about the situation at hand and he spoke,” said James. “And so many people could have been harmed not only financially, physically, emotionally, spiritually. So just be careful what we tweet and say and we do, even though, yes, we do have freedom of speech, but there can be a lot of negative that comes with that, too.”

James clarified his comment, stating he didn’t say Morey was “misinformed” on Hong Kong’s protests, but was rather highlighting how impactful tweeting could be. He said Morey’s “timing was off” and he should have waited until the NBA players left China. Then he contradicted himself.

“And for me personally, you guys know that when I speak about something, I speak about something I’m very knowledgeable about, something I’m very passionate about. I feel like with this particular situation, it was something not only I was not informed enough about. I just felt like it was something that not only myself or my teammates or my organisation had enough information to even talk about it at that point in time, and we still feel the same way.”

UFC’s Covington calls out LeBron James over Hong Kong

James was trying to say he wasn’t educated enough to comment on Hong Kong, but was totally fine with commenting on someone who did form an opinion on Hong Kong. But then he tried to walk that statement back altogether by saying it wasn’t about the content of Morey’s tweet, but the logistics of the tweet. Figure that one out.

James’ multiple, disjointed rebuttals angered Hongkongers and many who sympathised with the protest movement, which was wiped out early in 2020 by the coronavirus pandemic and later Hong Kong’s national security law. He’d taken a side, with protesters chanting “LeBron stands for money” as they burned his jerseys.

Turns out Morey was actually educated on the subject, as he revealed more than a year later he has friends from Hong Kong who he went to business school with, and was concerned for them.

Los Angeles Lakers forward LeBron James has drawn scorn for his stance, or lack there of, when it comes to Hong Kong and China. Photo: AP

James was well within his right not to comment on the situation, and just leave Morey’s tweet alone. No one would have held his feet to the fire if he just said he wasn’t educated enough on the situation to offer an informed opinion on it – which he did only after attacking Morey on the subject.

NBA commissioner Adam Silver backed Morey’s right to freedom of expression, course correcting after he said Morey’s tweet was regrettable – something that further enraged the Chinese Communist Party but showed the league was not going to kowtow. “I want this to be clear, and I think there’s been some confusion around this: We are not apologising for Daryl exercising his freedom of expression,” said Silver.

The incident holds interesting connotations looking at the recent statement James made in response to AC Milan striker Zlatan Ibrahimovic calling out his political stances. Ibrahimovic, who himself has made political statements, basically said athletes should stick to playing sports and not get into politics.

‘Redeem Team’ in Beijing 2008 was most important US golds

““I like him (James) a lot. He’s phenomenal, but I don’t like when people with a status speak about politics. Do what you’re good at doing,” Ibrahimovic wrote.

James responded by saying he would “never shut up about things that are wrong”.

“I preach about my people and I preach about equality, social injustice, racism, systematic voter suppression, things that go on in our community,” he said, talking about a school he set up in his hometown which serves underprivileged kids. “I’m their voice and I use my platform to continue to shed light on everything that may be going on not only in my community but around this country and around the world.”

LeBron James hits back at Ibrahimovic, Jeremy Lin backs NBA star

James said he understood how powerful his voice was, and that he has a platform to bring light to social justice issues. “I speak from a very educated mind. I’m kind of the wrong guy to actually go at because I do my homework.”

His business interests in China are well known, his jersey the biggest seller on the mainland, and he is by far the most recognisable NBA star. There is no denying he lost a fair chunk of change due to Morey’s tweet given James has a US$1 billion lifetime deal with Nike, a company with deep ties and footholds across the mainland.

Many took James’ scolding of Morey as backing China over those seeking increased autonomy for Hong Kong, and it’s tough to see how that isn’t the reality. UFC loudmouth fighter and Donald Trump supporter Colby Covington called James a “Chinese finger puppet” in a tweet, stating he was a “slimeball” for standing for social justice but not commenting on Hong Kong and lambasting someone who did.

01:43

Foreign diplomats show support for Hong Kong activists detained under national security law

Foreign diplomats show support for Hong Kong activists detained under national security law
Agreeing with Covington, unnecessary insults aside, is painful, but he may have a point. James has positioned himself as an active, global champion for social justice. But when it comes to Hong Kong’s dissident crushing national security law and saying anything negative about China’s many social justice issues, it appears James is tight-lipped.

Morey, according to James, shouldn’t have commented on it at all, but James was more than willing to speak about Morey’s comment. Sounds like do as I say, not as I do.

Maybe King James has a blind spot when it comes to social justice matters here in Hong Kong. Or, in his world, it’s totally fine to pick and choose which issues you like, which ones you support, and which ones you don’t for the sake of your bank account. Sounds like having your cake and eating it too.

3