Explainer | How Binance, FTX deal rocked the crypto world and then collapsed
- Zhao and Bankman-Fried have been trading barbs on Twitter for months, feuding over issues ranging from lobbying US politicians to allegations of front-running trades
- Late Wednesday afternoon New York time, Binance said it was pulling out of its deal to buy FTX.com, saying its rival’s issues were ‘beyond our control or ability to help’
It has been a tumultuous few days in the largely unregulated cryptocurrency world, with mudslinging on Twitter, a shock exchange takeover bid – which then collapsed – and plunging token values.
On Tuesday, the world’s biggest exchange, Binance Holdings, was set to acquire troubled rival FTX.com. On Wednesday, Binance walked away from the deal citing problems with FTX’s finances as well as potential regulatory investigations. Its decision to walk away deepened the ongoing crypto rout, with bitcoin tumbling to the lowest level in two years.
While crypto might seem like a niche corner of finance, the saga between two of its top players has upended the crypto ecosystem and is likely to have far-reaching repercussions.
What are Binance and FTX?
They are two of the biggest crypto exchanges, which are marketplaces where investors buy, sell and store tokens. Binance is the biggest crypto exchange by volume by a long way – and FTX is in the top five, according to crypto data provider CoinMarketCap (which is owned by Binance).
Who runs them?
They have also been led by two of the most visible and charismatic people in the crypto world: Binance by Zhao Changpeng (or CZ, as he is known), and FTX by Sam Bankman-Fried (or SBF).
Formerly a trader at Jane Street, until just a few weeks ago the curly-haired 30-year-old was everywhere in the crypto industry – backing flailing projects including BlockFi, Voyager Digital and Celsius. He counted the likes of Softbank Vision Fund, Singapore wealth fund Temasek and Ontario Teachers’ Pension Plan as investors.
Zhao is a China-born Canadian citizen who emigrated to Vancouver aged 12 and graduated with a degree in computer science from McGill University in Montreal. He started Binance in 2017 in Shanghai – but the Chinese government banned crypto exchanges the same year. He is now based in Dubai.
Why did they fall out?
Back in 2019, Binance invested in FTX, then a derivatives exchange. The next year, Binance launched its own crypto derivatives, quickly becoming the leader in the field.
Tensions rose as the two companies increasingly took divergent tacks with regulators. Bankman-Fried was testifying in the US Congress, while Binance was said to be facing regulatory probes around the world.
The two companies have also been competing for assets, with both bidding for assets of Voyager Digital. FTX.US, the American affiliate of FTX, won the auction.
Zhao and Bankman-Fried have been trading barbs on Twitter for months, feuding over issues ranging from lobbying US politicians to allegations of front-running trades.
So what just happened in the crypto world?
Over the weekend Zhao tweeted that Binance would be liquidating its holdings of a token known as FTT, which is issued by FTX.
The tweet followed a story from crypto news outlet CoinDesk saying that Alameda Research, a trading house owned by FTX’s founder Bankman-Fried, had a lot of its assets in FTT token.
That fuelled broader concerns about FTX’s health and investors began to withdraw money. The FTT token plunged. A day before reaching a deal, Bankman-Fried said on Twitter that assets on FTX were “fine” and that “a competitor is trying to go after us with false rumours”.
On Tuesday, CZ announced a potential takeover of FTX, with due diligence to be conducted “in the coming days”.
Then late Wednesday afternoon New York time, Binance said it was pulling out of the deal saying its rival’s issues were “beyond our control or ability to help”. Binance executives had discovered a gap between FTX’s liabilities and assets that may amount to more than US$6 billion, a person familiar with the matter told Bloomberg.
In addition, US regulators are investigating whether FTX properly handled customer funds, as well as its relationship with other parts of Bankman-Fried’s crypto empire, including his trading house Alameda Research, Bloomberg News reported on Wednesday.
What does this mean for the markets?
It has injected a lot of uncertainty for investors who are worried about the potential for spreading contagion given the pivotal role FTX and its co-founder Sam Bankman-Fried played in the industry.
FTT, the utility token of the FTX exchange, collapsed by more than 40 per cent Wednesday following a tumble of more than 70 per cent Tuesday. But just about every digital coin is struggling.
Bitcoin fell as much as 15 per cent to US$15,987 on Wednesday, the least since November 2020, which leaves a lot of holders under water.
What does this mean for FTX users?
That is unclear. Clients worried about the future of the exchange have already pulled out US$430 million worth of bitcoin in the space of just four days.
How does this affect CZ and SBF?
It is a huge comedown for SBF, who had previously been seen as one of the most accomplished people in the industry.
That is playing out in fortunes, as well. Bankman-Fried’s 53 per cent stake in FTX was worth about US$6.2 billion before Tuesday’s takeover, according to the Bloomberg Billionaires Index, based on that fundraising round and the subsequent performance of publicly traded crypto companies. His crypto trading house, Alameda Research, contributed US$7.4 billion to his personal fortune.
The Bloomberg wealth index assumes existing FTX investors, including Bankman-Fried, will be completely wiped out by Binance’s bailout, and that the root of the exchange’s problems stemmed from Alameda. As a result, both FTX and Alameda are given a US$1 value. That leaves SBF’s net worth at about US$1 billion, down from US$15.6 billion heading into Tuesday. The 94 per cent loss is the biggest one-day collapse ever among billionaires tracked by Bloomberg.
Even after pulling out of the deal, Bankman-Fried’s fall from grace leaves CZ as the top person in the crypto world. He is had a rough period too, with his fortune down 84 per cent year-to-date, according to the Billionaires Index – but he is still estimated to be worth US$14.9 billion.
What does this mean in terms of regulation?
This episode and how quickly it unfolded provide a stark example for regulators who have been concerned about the lack of guardrails in the freewheeling crypto space. Jurisdictions that have been considering looser rules may be less likely to do so – especially on the back a few months ago of implosions in the Terra/Luna ecosystem and hedge fund Three Arrows Capital.
Bankman-Fried told FTX.com investors on Wednesday that the company needs a cash injection, or else it would need to file for bankruptcy, Bloomberg News reported.
Whether FTX survives this crisis or not, the entire industry is on edge about the risks of contagion.