Advertisement

Opinion | India should ignore US-China politics in making Huawei call

  • India should be clear-eyed about the benefits and costs of engaging with the Chinese firm, rather than get lost in a debate about geopolitics
  • But it should be under no illusions about Huawei and its ties to the Chinese state

Reading Time:4 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
A new battleground is looming in the US-China tussle over Huawei: India. Photo: Bloomberg

India’s decision whether to allow Chinese telecommunications companies, including Huawei, a role in its 5G trials is being keenly watched, not only in the country but also in the United States and China.

Advertisement
 The question of 5G has emerged as a particularly thorny issue in the US-China trade war, with Washington calling on its allies and partners to exclude Chinese vendors from their networks. The US has already warned Britain that including Chinese vendors in its 5G network could compromise future US-Britain information sharing and cooperation, because of the security implications.

 Nevertheless, Huawei is already reportedly helping four of Britain’s mobile operators to build their networks, and Britain has appeared to have taken a call to allow Chinese equipment in what is being called “noncore” components of its 5G infrastructure.

 The US message to Britain was one that was repeated last month by Secretary of State Mike Pompeo, during his visit to Delhi, and by President Donald Trump during his meetings with Prime Minister Narendra Modi at the G20 Summit in Osaka, where India-US 5G cooperation was discussed.
China, meanwhile, has urged India to include Huawei in its trials.

During a visit to India this week, Yang Yanyi, a former Chinese envoy to the EU and currently a member of the foreign affairs committee of the Chinese People’s Political Consultative Conference, a political advisory body, said India should not be “exclusive” in its choice.

Advertisement
Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi and President Donald Trump are thought to have discussed India-US 5G cooperation at the G20 in Osaka. Photo: Washington Post
Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi and President Donald Trump are thought to have discussed India-US 5G cooperation at the G20 in Osaka. Photo: Washington Post

Yang, leading a delegation on trade issues, was quoted in the Indian media as slamming Washington, saying it “should be ashamed for trying to exert state power to suppress a Chinese company and other companies from developing countries from excelling in [telecommunications]”.

Advertisement