Advertisement

Opinion | Massive stimulus packages not enough to rescue coronavirus-hit economies

  • Size does not necessarily matter when it comes to stimulus packages, amid concerns over dysfunctional execution, haphazard allocation and weak accountability
  • In Southeast Asia, where governments have shown a willingness to spend, there is good reason to question some of the measures being rolled out

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
An intersection in Kuala Lumpur, as Malaysia eases its coronavirus restrictions to allow economic activity to resume. Economists say stimulus packages should be administered carefully and only spent in necessary areas. Photo: Xinhua
The battlefield terminology of “fiscal bazookas” and “fiscal firepower” used to describe governments’ massive stimulus packages give the impression that big spending alone will lift coronavirus-wracked economies out of their current doom.

Unveiling Germany’s post-pandemic stimulus package of US$146 billion earlier this month, the usually tight-fisted Finance Minister Olaf Scholz sought to tap on that warlike rhetoric, saying the measures would bring Europe’s largest economy out of the downturn with a “ka-boom”.

Market watchers say they expect more buoyancy in weeks to come as investors too are vested in the belief that unprecedented fiscal spending is a cure-all, even if a second wave of the pandemic comes around.

Advertisement

Expectations are rising that the United States may soon lay out a fresh US$1-3 trillion package in addition to the more than US$3 trillion pumped out since the virus outbreak began.

I have to admit, I too have found myself quite in awe of the headline sums of fiscal injections bandied about in recent months by Southeast Asian leaders, whom I track closely.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x