Advertisement
China-Japan relations
This Week in AsiaPolitics

Forced labour a sore topic between South Korea and Japan as court verdict looms

  • Since 2012, there have been flurry of lawsuits seeking to overturn historical legal decisions favouring Japanese firms who used conscripted workers
  • But experts say wrangling in courts may be a setback for reconciliation efforts

Reading Time:5 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
South Korean Lee Chun-sik, 94, was a victim of forced labour during Japan’s colonial rule of the Korean peninsula before the end of the second world war – and was granted compensation from a Japanese company in an October 30 ruling. Photo: AP
Gigi Choy
When it comes to sore topics between South Korea and Japan over the second world war, it’s not just “comfort women” that are a source of pain – there are also long-standing historical tensions over forced labour.

Nearly 150,000 Koreans were conscripted to help the Japanese war effort by working in factories and mines in Japan. South Korea says 5,000 victims of these wartime forced labourers are still alive.

So an upcoming decision by South Korea’s Supreme Court on a forced labour case involving Japanese firm Mitsubishi Heavy Industries, set for November 29, is being keenly watched – especially as it comes after the top court’s October 30 decision ordering Nippon Steel & Sutimoto Metal to compensate four Koreans for forced labour during Japanese colonial rule.
Advertisement

The November verdict will be on an appeal to a 2013 High Court ruling ordering Mitsubishi to pay 80 million won (US$71,000) to each of the five plaintiffs who claim they were exposed to radiation from the 1945 atomic bombing of Hiroshima while conscripted as forced labourers.

In 2012, South Korea’s Supreme Court began overturning High Court decisions in favour of Japanese corporations.

Advertisement

“Korean courts are giving plaintiffs a second chance by presiding over lawsuits, many of which were already adjudicated in Japan,” said Timothy Webster, associate professor of transnational law at Case Western Reserve University. Webster said the court’s decision in the Nippon Steel case suggested Korean plaintiffs were more likely to win their lawsuits on home turf.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x