Advertisement
Advertisement
US Presidential Election 2020
Get more with myNEWS
A personalised news feed of stories that matter to you
Learn more
US presidential candidate Joe Biden with his running mate Kamala Harris. Photo: EPA

As India celebrates Joe Biden’s running mate Kamala Harris, a question over China and regrets over Namaste Trump

  • Kamala Harris is the first Asian-American to appear on a major presidential ticket and her heritage has given the Indian public cause to celebrate
  • But policymakers are nervous that the Narendra Modi administration’s cosiness with Donald Trump may come back to haunt it
A wave of excitement swept through India when US Democratic presidential candidate Joe Biden announced Senator Kamala Harris as his running mate on Wednesday.

Harris, a child of immigrant parents from Jamaica and India, is the first Asian-American and Black woman to appear on a major party’s presidential ticket.

But observers caution that despite her heritage, Harris has remained a tough critic of India’s domestic policies under Prime Minister Narendra Modi. She has also spoken out over Beijing’s human rights practices and its treatment of Hong Kong.

Harris’ family history has made her popular with the Indian public, with celebrities, industrialists and even politicians celebrating the announcement.

Her late mother, Shyamala Gopalan, was born in Chennai, the capital of Tamil Nadu state, and studied in the United States for her master’s degree and PhD before becoming a breast cancer specialist. Gopalan married Donald Harris, a fellow doctorate of Jamaican origin who is a professor emeritus at Stanford University, and they had two children – Kamala, born in 1964, and her sister Maya.

03:10

Who is Kamala Harris? Joe Biden’s vice-president pick

Who is Kamala Harris? Joe Biden’s vice-president pick

The VP nominee has often talked about her Indian family and has called her mother and her grandfather, PV Gopalan, two of the “most influential people in my life”. PV Gopalan was a freedom fighter who took part in India’s bid to overthrow British colonial rule.

Her mother’s family still lives in India.

“There is no question about how happy we are,” Harris’ maternal uncle, Balachandran Gopalan, an academic in the Indian capital of New Delhi, said on Wednesday.

“She is a very committed personality – committed to public service and most importantly committed to common human decency.”

Rival to running mate: what ‘fearless fighter’ Kamala Harris brings to Joe Biden’s bid

Shyamala Gopalan would often bring her daughters to India and when she died in 2009, Harris returned “to immerse her ashes in the Bay of Bengal”, the uncle said.

Although Harris did not speak Tamil, the language of the southern state, “she can understand a little bit”, he said.

Balachandran Gopalan said the nomination of Kamala – whose name means “lotus” in Tamil, as well as in Sanskrit and Hindi – was a “big deal” for Indian-Americans.

01:34

Trump ‘pleaded’ for China to help him get re-elected, writes former US adviser Bolton in new book

Trump ‘pleaded’ for China to help him get re-elected, writes former US adviser Bolton in new book

“So far [Indian-Americans] have only achieved high professional jobs, but this is one of the highest political jobs,” he said.

Harris’ aunt Sarala Gopalan, a doctor who still lives in the city her big sister left at 19, said the entire family was “thrilled and happy”.

“A friend of mine in the United States gave us the message at 4am and we have been up since then,” Sarala Gopalan told news channel CNN-News18.

“She is a person who never forgets her roots and believes in family values,” she told the Deccan Herald newspaper.

As Namaste Trump meets Howdy Modi in India, common threat China looms large

“Even today, she calls me chithi, and she has always been a caring person,” she said, using the Tamil word for a mother’s younger sister.

And since Harris’ mother is no longer alive, “we will always be available for Kamala and Maya”.

Sarala Gopalan called Harris an “ambitious girl” with a “fighting spirit” who knew what she wanted to achieve.

“She is not scared of anything and will fight for everything she aims to achieve,” Sarala told the Indian website Rediff.com in 2016, soon after Harris won the Senate seat for California. But Harris would “not stop there”, she said.

Kamala Harris, while campaigning in the presidential nomination race. Photo: Reuters

Harris, now 55, was the first woman of South Asian heritage elected to the Senate and was California’s first Black attorney general, as well as being the first woman to hold the post.

The South Asian Americans Leading Together (SAALT), a US-based non-profit organisation, called Harris’ nomination “historic” but cautioned against focusing only on her ethnic background.

“As exciting as it is to have an Asian-American in this role, identity alone doesn’t guarantee a candidate has taken or will take actions that support and uplift South Asian communities alongside other Black and brown communities in the US,” said Lakshmi Sridaran, SAALT’s executive director.

WHAT ABOUT HER POLICIES?

Amid the attention on Harris’ heritage, some observers are waiting to see what position she will take on the policies of Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi, who has taken an increasingly nationalistic stance in recent years.
Last year, New Delhi imposed a communications blockade and lockdown on Jammu & Kashmir, after revoking the region’s special status.
While Indian diplomats say there is “worry” around how a Biden administration would react to New Delhi’s policies, they say much depends on how he sees the subcontinent fitting into his China policies.

Already, Biden has criticised Delhi’s changes to its citizenship laws last year, which make it harder for Muslim refugees from neighbouring countries to gain Indian citizenship while fast-tracking refugees of other religions.

An Indian soldier in Kashmir. Photo: Xinhua

Harris, in the same vein, has opposed India’s actions in Jammu & Kashmir, saying she would keep a close eye on the situation and wanted to “remind the Kashmiris that they are not alone”.

“There is a need to intervene if the situation demands. It comes under American values to raise the issue of human rights,” she said last September.

Harris had also criticised a decision by Indian Foreign Minister S Jaishankar to cancel his meeting with a US Congressional panel because member Pramila Jayapal had moved a resolution asking India to lift the blockade.

Harris said she stood with Jayapal and that it was “wrong for any foreign government” to dictate the participation of members in meetings on Capitol Hill.

What Kamala Harris believes: issues, policy positions and votes for Biden’s VP pick

Sridaran from SAALT said Harris would be judged for her response on such issues.

“It is critical for South Asians in the US to assess whether the campaign has taken a clear stance against harmful policies and actions in the subcontinent that impact the diaspora here, such as the violence of Hindu nationalism,” she said.

Former Indian ambassador Rajiv Bhatia said that a Democratic win in November would have an impact on ties.

“The stance of the Democratic Party on issues like Kashmir, Pakistan and human rights is such that India should be ready to face some turbulence on these issues,” he said.
Indian Foreign Minister Subrahmanyam Jaishankar. Photo: EPA

New Delhi should not expect undue concessions as Harris “is American, she is not Indian”, but her ascent to the VP’s seat would still “make a difference”.

“Her Indian origin will mean we will have, in the high echelons, somebody who fully understands India’s culture and what drives India,” he said.

Another factor that concerns New Delhi is the perception that it might have tilted too much in favour of the Donald Trump presidency.

How Trump reacted to Biden’s VP pick Kamala Harris: she’s horrible and nasty

Last year, the Indian-American community and supporters of Modi invited Trump to an event titled “Howdy Modi”, which was seen as an attempt to help the president gain popularity with the 4 million-strong diaspora.

In February, India hosted Trump in the western Indian city of Ahmedabad for a similar public event titled “Namaste Trump”.

A former diplomat in New Delhi, who served in Washington, said such events had created a perception of “closeness”.

“So, yes, it is a worry that a new presidency, shaped by a known critic of the Modi administration, might emerge,” the envoy said. “Amid that, the perception that we are close to the Trump administration will not help.”

THE CHINA FACTOR

Another issue being watched is how the Biden-Harris campaign handles the issue of China. Washington and Beijing have locked horns over trade, the treatment of Uygurs in Xinjiang and the status of Hong Kong.

Last month, the US ordered the Chinese government to shut its Houston consulate, which triggered a tit-for-tat by Beijing, which shut the US consulate in Chengdu.

Harris, in an interview with the Council on Foreign Relations last year, called China’s human rights record “abysmal” and said she would seek a global consensus on “confronting China” on the issue of “troubling trade practices”.

China ‘set to shut US consulate’ in response to Houston closure

Harris also backed a bill in the Senate to impose economic sanctions on individuals deemed to have violated the terms of Hong Kong’s degree of autonomy from mainland China.

However, Bhatia, the former ambassador, said greater clarity was needed on her position towards China. “We need to see whether there is a consensus in the US [across party lines] that China is the chief adversary.”

Such an agreement would shape Washington’s ties with Delhi, Bhatia said.

“No matter what Washington’s policies are in the new presidency, the key players in Asia will remain China, Russia and India,” he said.

Post