A message for US and China as India and Russia put two and two together
- A meeting of the Indian and Russian foreign and defence ministers has a purpose beyond clearing up bilateral misunderstandings, experts say
- New Delhi reminds US of its strategic autonomy and soothes Russian qualms about Quad. Moscow tells Beijing it will keep selling arms to China’s Himalayan rival
New Delhi was keen to demonstrate that it retained its “strategic autonomy” in a signal to Washington, said Kanwal Sibal, a former Indian foreign secretary. The US has been trying to wean India off of Russian influence and has tried to discourage it from buying weapons from Moscow, its largest defence supplier, by threatening it with sanctions.
“The signal to China is politically important,” said Sibal. “It is Russia’s way of telling China that their close strategic relations will not limit Russia’s choices with India and that the strands of its policy are independent of each other. It also means that Russia will continue to supply advanced weapons to India.”
MEETING OF FRIENDS
Analysts said that despite the positive language the dialogue was more aimed at clearing up misunderstandings on various thorny issues – including India’s involvement in the US-led Quad – that had been accumulating in recent years.
“This dialogue comes at the right time,” said Alexey Kupriyanov, a senior research fellow at the Russian Academy of Sciences’ Institute of World Economy and International Relations.
“Many unresolved issues have accumulated between Russia and India and a certain misunderstanding has arisen regarding many external policy concepts and actions, like the Indo-Pacific.”
Analysts said India would be keen to show Russia that its involvement in the Quad did not mean it had given up its long-held stance of strategic autonomy or that it was distancing itself from its links with Moscow.
Kupriyanov said the two-plus-two was an effective tool for resolving these misunderstandings and moving on to “practical interactions” in areas of mutual interest.
Navtej Sarna, a retired diplomat and former Indian ambassador to Washington, said a political-military discussion made sense in a “multi-power” world and was “a good step at a time when the Russia-China relationship has been growing warmer”.
“The two-plus-two meeting was long overdue and has been talked about for months,” said Nandan Unnikrishnan, a distinguished fellow at the Delhi-based think-tank Observer Research Foundation.
India-Russia defence ties deepen even as Moscow cosies up to Beijing
India has had recent two-plus-two meetings with all the other members of the Quad. The two-plus-two meeting with Russia will be its first with a non-Quad member.
“It is a very significant development that shows our relations with Russia are as important as India’s relations with the US, Japan and Australia,” said Gautam Bambawale, who was India’s ambassador to China from 2017 to 2018. He said it would also show China that India-Russia ties would not be affected by the Russia-China relationship.
While India and Russia have enjoyed strong ties for decades, in recent years India’s decision to buy defence equipment from other countries, including the US, as well as its growing diplomatic ties with the US, have raised concerns in Moscow.
Though Russia continues to be India’s main arms supplier, its share of the market is dropping. Between 2010 and 2014 it provided 70 per cent of India’s defence equipment; in the following four-year period it supplied just 58 per cent, according to the Stockholm Peace Research Institute.
Sibal said Russia needn’t be concerned about the Quad. “The objective of the Quad is to counter China’s threat. Russia is not the common concern. If Russia was also the aim, India would not have joined,” he said.
Unnikrishnan said the talks could also assuage Russian concerns about how its weapons were being used.
Could Russia side with the US and India against China?
“I would not be surprised if in the coming days Russia also insists on some foundational agreements, as the US has done, to ensure that the sophisticated weaponry it gives India is not accessed by other countries,” he said.
The forum will also provide a chance for candid discussions on other areas of mutual concern.
“There is uncertainty about the future of Afghanistan and there is a gap between India and Russia on [this matter],” Sibal noted.
“This new forum will be helpful in understanding the stakes each country has in Afghanistan and how they can prepare for unforeseen developments following a potential Taliban take over.”