Advertisement
Advertisement
Japan
Get more with myNEWS
A personalised news feed of stories that matter to you
Learn more
Chinese tourists arrive at Haneda Airport. Survey respondents that spoke to This Week in Asia clarified they did not dislike the Chinese people and culture, with their negative feelings only aimed at the Chinese government. Photo: Bloomberg

Most Japanese do not have ‘friendly feelings’ towards China amid Beijing’s aggression in South China Sea, Taiwan: poll

  • Some 86 per cent of the 3,000 respondents in the Cabinet Office survey were concerned about China’s aggression in the South China Sea, Taiwan and the Diaoyu Islands
  • Survey respondents that spoke to This Week in Asia clarified they did not dislike the Chinese people and culture, with their negative feelings only aimed at the Chinese government
Japan
Less than 13 per cent of Japanese have positive or “friendly feelings” towards China, according to the latest results of an annual government poll, the lowest since Tokyo introduced the survey in 1978.
The negative feelings of 86.7 per cent of the 3,000 respondents to the Cabinet Office survey, released on Friday, were reflected in interviews conducted by This Week in Asia, with many Japanese expressing concerns about Beijing’s increasingly aggressive moves in the South China Sea, as well as against Taiwan and the Diaoyu Islands that Japan calls the Senkaku Islands, which Beijing claims.
Some respondents also expressed dismay at the way the Uygurs of Xinjiang have been treated and the loss of democratic freedoms among the people of Hong Kong.

Upgrade of Japan-Asean ties a ‘natural’ move amid growing Chinese influence

Survey respondents that spoke to This Week in Asia, however, emphasised that they did not dislike the Chinese people and that they held largely positive feelings towards Chinese cuisine, history, art and culture. Their dislike was aimed primarily at the government in Beijing and the Communist Party.

“The aversion that many in Japan feel towards the government in Beijing or the Communist Party is shared, I believe, by people in other countries in the free world,” said Yoichi Shimada, a professor of international relations at Fukui Prefectural University.

“Japan is just geographically closer to China, and it is our territory that Beijing is claiming, so it comes as no surprise if the distrust of China is greater here,” he told This Week in Asia.

Pedestrians walk past advertising for an entertainment establishment in the Minowa area of Tokyo. Photo: AFP
Many Japanese have positive feelings towards Taiwan, Shimada said, so when Beijing ramps up rhetoric against Taiwan or conducts threatening military moves close to its coast, distrust of China worsens while sympathy or support for Taiwan increases.

Ken Kato, a Tokyo-based businessman, echoed the belief that Japanese do not like to be “bullied” or see others treated in the same way.

“We see on the news that pretty much every day the Chinese military is threatening the Japanese Senkaku Islands, and it is inevitable that people are angry,” he said. “And we see how the people of Tibet and Xinjiang are treated, and how the freedom of the people of Hong Kong has disappeared.”
“I do not blame Chinese people for this, but I do see the Communist Party acting in ways that are completely against our democratic values,” he said. “In truth, many people in Japan also see Chinese people as victims of the party.”

02:16

Japan’s military holds drill on island potentially vulnerable to China

Japan’s military holds drill on island potentially vulnerable to China

Maya Hamada, a professor of Chinese literature at Kobe University, says the image of China among the vast majority of young Japanese is “very negative”, which may be contributing to the gradual decline in numbers of those studying Chinese language, literature and culture.

“There has clearly been fewer and fewer people interested in studying Chinese since around 2019, with many young people shocked at the actions and image of China in the early stages of the pandemic.”

“But I believe that my students do distinguish between ordinary Chinese people and the government,” she added.

And Hamada is not optimistic that things will improve, in part because her experiences have shown that the Chinese are just as hostile towards Japan.

“I went to Beijing last autumn, and it was clear that attitudes towards Japan and the Japanese are becoming more negative and severe,” she said. “People there repeatedly asked me what I thought about the release of water from the Fukushima nuclear power plant and, when I expressed my opinion, it was clear that Chinese people believe what their government tells them through the media about Fukushima.”

‘Clickbait’: Japan slams UK tabloid report linking dead fish to Fukushima water

Personal friends with experience of Japan and Japanese people were more open to alternative viewpoints, Hamada said, but “everything on the internet and on television takes whatever Japan does and finds a way to be critical”.

“It seems to me that the government’s policy is to make the people dislike Japan to praise and elevate their own country, which is exactly what the extreme right-wing does here in Japan,” she added.

That distrust of Japan’s neighbour appears to carry over into the commercial sector. Another survey, released on January 15 by the Japanese Chamber of Commerce and Industry in China, indicated that just 15 per cent of member companies increased investment in China last year, while 48 per cent did not invest in their Chinese operations or cut spending.

There have been reports of Japanese companies shrinking their operations in China and some shifting their manufacturing operations to other countries entirely, with Vietnam being a popular destination for firms. Rising costs in China are a factor for many, but some officials have expressed concern about the theft of intellectual property and the arrest of Japanese businesspeople on flimsy charges of espionage.

People walk in front of an electronic stock board showing Japan’s Nikkei 225 index in Tokyo. A survey by the Japanese Chamber of Commerce and Industry in China showed just 15 per cent of member companies increased investment in China last year, while 48 per cent did not invest in their Chinese operations or cut spending. Photo: AP

“There are many in Japan who believe companies should accelerate their withdrawal from China because of the intimidation that businesspeople there are experiencing,” Shimada said. “There is also deep concern about advanced Japanese technology in areas such as IT, which we know China is seeking to access.”

Yet there are signs that some Japanese politicians are attempting to build bridges with Beijing.

Mizuho Fukushima, head of the opposition Social Democratic Party, visited China last week and met senior government officials to discuss improving bilateral relations. In a meeting with Wang Huning, the fourth-highest ranked official in the Communist Party, the SDP leader was told that Beijing hopes to improve ties and “constructively manage differences”, Jiji Press reported.

Analysts pointed out, however, that there is little chance of Fukushima influencing the policies of either government as the SDP has little power in Japan and, with the public concerned about China’s growing influence, is unlikely to win any new followers by appearing in Beijing.

96