Hong Kong teacher's deregistration for independence lesson plans 'not a free speech issue', says education secretary

  • Two hour-long lessons primary school lessons focused on freedom of speech and Taiwan, Tibet and Xinjiang
  • Kevin Yeung denounced the time spent talking about the banned Hong Kong National Party and that whether it influenced students to support independence was 'not the point'
South China Morning Post |

Latest Articles

Face Off: Should Hong Kong abolish ranking systems from report cards?

Artist who left Hong Kong for Britain illustrates her nostalgia for the city

A student walks into the Alliance Primary School in Kowloon Tong. Photo: SCMP/ Felix Wong

Hong Kong's secretary for education said that a teacher's deregistration for creating lesson plans that mentioned Hong Kong independence was not a free speech issue, as other examples could have been used to make a similar point.

Kevin Yeung Yun-hung’s defence of the move came as the chairman of a primary school heads alliance said the Education Bureau’s decision had “caused waves in the sector” and was disagreed with by many.

Although Alliance Primary School students interviewed by officials denied the class had led them to support Hong Kong independence, Yeung on Wednesday insisted that was “not the point”.

“There are many other examples that could be used to discuss freedom of speech,” Yeung said on a local radio programme. 

Beijing liaison office head calls for increased national education

“In the lesson plan, almost 50 minutes was spent discussing the Hong Kong National Party and its manifesto and the conclusion even mentions Taiwan, Xinjiang and Tibetan independence. You have to question why the example used would be a banned organisation,” he said, referring to the separatist party, which was outlawed by the government in 2018.

The Education Bureau announced late on Monday night it had stripped the teacher who wrote the lesson plan of his registration, accusing him of “spreading the idea of Hong Kong independence” in violation of the Basic Law, the city’s mini-constitution. It marked the first time a teacher had been deregistered for misconduct. 

The classroom materials allegedly asked Primary Five students to answer four questions after showing them a TV documentary featuring pro-independence activist Andy Chan Ho-tin. The classes took place in March 2019, and a parent filed a complaint the following September.

Education secretary Kevin Yeung on Wednesday defended the decision to strip a teacher of their registration for discussing Hong Kong independence in a lesson plan. Photo: SCMP/ Dickson Lee

An internal investigation concluded the other staff members involved were not advocating Hong Kong independence, but authorities issued reprimands and warnings to the principal, vice-principal and the three teachers who administered the lesson plans for lax supervision, eventually moving to deregister the educator who created them.

A source said that education officials had visited the school and interviewed students about the lesson. On Wednesday, Yeung confirmed the visit but did not confirm if they had spoken to students. 

“But whether the students support Hong Kong independence is not the point. While they can collect information from different sources and reach their own conclusions, this does not mean the topic is appropriate,” Yeung said. 

The education minister also defended the investigation process, saying the teacher in question had been given two opportunities to send in written explanations, noting he could still appeal if he was unhappy with the decision.

Murder suspect who triggered anti-government protests is 'essentially a free man'

However, the deregistration has been widely criticised by the education sector. Cheung Yung-pong, honorary chairman of the Aided Primary School Heads Association, told a radio programme on Wednesday the decision had “caused waves in the sector”. 

“We knew something like this was coming, we just did not think it would happen to a primary schoolteacher,” Cheung said. “Many of the primary school heads contacted me and said they disagree with the decision.” 

Cheung said he hoped the government would hold discussions with teachers in the field about appropriate penalties for different situations rather than resorting to deregistration. 

Opposition lawmaker Ip Kin-yuen, meanwhile, of the 100,000-strong Professional Teachers’ Union, said even if an appeal failed, the union would seek a judicial review. 

Sign up for the YP Teachers Newsletter
Get updates for teachers sent directly to your inbox
By registering, you agree to our T&C and Privacy Policy