Hong Kong protests: Secondary school students avoid jail for trashing store during demonstrations

  • Principal Magistrate Peter Law sentenced the four girls to community service or probation, but said it wouldn’t have been harsh to send them to prison
  • The target was Best Mart 360, which came under fire during the pro-democracy protests for alleged ties to gangs in China’s Fujian province

Latest Articles

Why do we dream? The science of sleep

Hong Kong Science Fair showcases power of creativity

Hot Topics: What’s next for Hong Kong schools that didn’t meet minimum enrollment?

Eastern Court handed four girls probation and community service orders for their roles in trashing a snacks shop in 2019. Photo: SCMP/ Nora Tam

Four secondary school students avoided being sent to prison on Wednesday after they admitted to vandalising a snacks store during Hong Kong’s 2019 anti-government protests.

Instead, Eastern Court either gave the girls community service orders or placed them on probation at the request of defence lawyers.

Principal Magistrate Peter Law Tak-chuen said he was satisfied the four would receive adequate support from their families and teachers in turning over a new leaf without being sentenced to correctional training.

National security guidelines released for schools

But he warned the four: “These are no light punishments. It would not have been harsh to sentence you all to prison, because this was an act of lawlessness.”

The case centred on a flashmob attack on the Best Mart 360 branch at Metroplaza in Kwai Chung on October 13, 2019, when protesters responded to online calls to stage demonstrations in shopping malls across the city.

The retailer came under attack following unsubstantiated claims that its chairman had ties to gangs from the Chinese province of Fujian, which had been blamed by protesters for instigating violent street clashes.

Student resentment about Covid-19 could lead to more protests

Prosecutors said eight black-clad protesters had trashed the store that afternoon, swiping goods off the shelves and damaging facilities.

Seven of them, including the four students – Chen Pui-ying and Tsang Tsz-in, both 17; Wong Sze-man, 18, and a 15-year-old girl – pleaded guilty to one joint charge of criminal damage after their arrest. The eighth suspect is still at large.

How does Telegram work and why is it so popular?

Two other defendants were previously sentenced to either jail or correctional training, while another 14-year-boy is expected to be sentenced on March 15.

On Wednesday, the magistrate ordered Chen, Tsang and Wong – all Form Six students – to serve 240 hours of community service. He handed the 15-year-old girl, a Form Five student, two years of probation, which requires her to observe a daily curfew and take part in educational activities per her supervising officer’s instructions.

Sign up for the YP Teachers Newsletter
Get updates for teachers sent directly to your inbox
By registering, you agree to our T&C and Privacy Policy