I don’t think it’s necessary. Some students feel uncomfortable when going to the mainland, so they may skip the visit or even behave badly during the tour. Therefore, they may not learn anything – this defeats the original purpose of widening students’ horizons. But what if the destination were changed to other places, such as Britain or Singapore? Without a doubt, students would enjoy going to these places more, and they would benefit immensely from it.
This is a really good idea. It seems that we always get information about our country from the internet or TV. If we went to the mainland, we could have first-hand experience of what’s happening there. We could compare our past learning experiences to what we actually saw on the tour. But I don’t think the tour should be made compulsory for all students. A lot of people will oppose such a ruling.
It’s a good move, but the itinerary has to be transparent, and students should be given a choice to go on the trip or stay behind in Hong Kong. By exposing them to the country’s development and people’s living conditions, students would get a better understanding about our motherland and be more tolerant towards mainlanders. A study tour could also help them to think independently, instead of being influenced by stereotypes or political propaganda.
Who would want to spend their entire school life in the classroom, if they had a chance to travel? In my opinion, we could learn the most when leaving our comfort zone and the setting of our daily lives. This way, you could challenge what you have learned so far, and sharpen your critical thinking skills.
I also believe that you could never really understand a topic teachers talk about in school if you have never really been in touch with it. For example, the Liberal Studies lessons address many mainland issues, but you could hardly comment on them if you have never really been there. Besides, a study tour would be welcomed by students who don’t get to travel a lot.
l think making a mainland study tour part of the local curriculum would be very meaningful. Hong Kong students are spoiled, and they take things such as food, water and good hygiene for granted. A trip to the mainland would make them realise that we have a lot of resources that many others lack. Then we would learn to cherish our resources and complain less about the government and society.
It will be a suitable opportunity to clear up misunderstandings for students from both places. They can see how the other group really lives and promote cultural exchange. It will be very interesting to see a new education system too.
In our next Talking Points, we'll discuss:
We are now accepting your answers for this topic. To take part, email your answer with your name, age, and school, along with a nice, clear selfie (make sure it’s not blurry), to [email protected] by lunchtime on Monday. Don’t forget to include “Talking Points” in the subject line.