• Wed
  • Jul 23, 2014
  • Updated: 4:29pm
NewsHong Kong

Book-borrowing from libraries 'costs publishers up to HK$105m a year in potential sales'

PUBLISHED : Wednesday, 18 June, 2014, 2:54am
UPDATED : Wednesday, 18 June, 2014, 2:54am

Book-borrowing from libraries costs the publishing industry up to HK$105 million a year in potential sales, according to a group lobbying for royalties to be paid on borrowed books.

The claim by the Hong Kong Public Lending Right Alliance follows a survey in which up to 65 per cent of public library users said they would not buy books if they could be borrowed from libraries.

The alliance, supported by almost 450 local authors, is seeking a public lending law under which royalties of up to HK$8 would be paid for each borrowing.

"The government said the lending services could promote the books among readers and have a positive impact on the selling of books," alliance chairman Derek Lee Wai-wing said yesterday. "But the findings have proven that the public library services have satisfied the need of most readers and lowered their appetite for buying books."

In the survey, commissioned by the alliance, about 20 per cent of respondents said they would buy a book after borrowing it because they liked it and of these just 1.7 per cent said they would do so frequently.

Authors' public lending rights have been recognised in at least 41 countries. If the local authors succeed in their campaign, Hong Kong will become the first region in Asia to adopt such a system.

Kenneth Hwang King-tin, who has published 31 books, said publishers now tended only to publish books by famous authors because it is expensive to put new books on shelves in bookstores which are suffering from high rents.

"With the lending right, publishers will be more willing to take the risk and support new authors, instead of just focusing on celebrities' photo books, recipes or financial books," Hwang said.

The alliance has previously proposed charging HK$3 to HK$8 each time a book is borrowed. The first 200 borrowings would be free and the charge would stop if a book had been borrowed over 8,000 times, according to the plan.

The Home Affairs Department said guidelines issued by the International Federation of Library Associations did not require the adoption of a public-lending-right system and it followed the principle of freedom of access to information and free access to public libraries.



For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive



This article is now closed to comments

Public libraries have been around since the 17th century and have proved their worth as a social amenity. The publishing world may believe that its interests are served by squeezing blood out of this public service, and they may even be right (though I doubt it) but they have to disprove the entire library concept before we should entertain their misplaced greed.
A more pressing case for public consideration is the changing nature of libraries, with the spread of online connectivity. It is right to ask who does and could benefit from library services, how libraries can adapt to remain useful and relevant, and even whether library expenditure should be cut.
But the starting point is the value to the community of the service.
So the authors want to stop the poor; elderly and disadvantaged from even having the right to read?
8 dollars for every checkout, even if the government will fork that out, it'll cost too much for some libraries to run, money that could be better spent on finding new books.


SCMP.com Account