Advertisement
US-China relations
Opinion

Trump’s mind and the reality show within: why China should worry

Tom Plate says the self-regarding mind of Donald Trump, as revealed in a recent impromptu interview, proves again that he is no Obama. And that adds a new layer of uncertainty to the US relationship with China

4-MIN READ4-MIN
Donald Trump’s mind tends towards the blunt-binary – “they” are either for us or against us. This kind of mind soaks in self-congratulation, ­almost bathing in a buoyant mentality that talks only to itself, as if to minimise contradiction or interruption. Illustration: Timothy McEvenue
Tom Plate

Recent US presidents, at least in public, would speak of China only after the vetting of practically every word, as if an ­errant one might prove seriously chancy. The bilateral relationship is too complex and freighted with too many tensions, and the stakes too high, to have it otherwise.

President Donald Trump is different and, in the back and forth ­between China and the United States, this lays on more uncertainty to the bilateral relationship. It’s as if the entire world – as one hypothesis making the rounds has it – exists within the confines of his own mind, so that, when that mind is turned off, as it were, the world sort of ceases to exist.

Absurd as that may seem, there is ample precedent for this view in classical philosophy. Bishop George Berkeley (1685-1753) ­defined reality as nothing more than a product of, and dependent on, the human mind – for what can really be said to exist outside the mind? Here in the quaint words of this landmark Irish philosopher: “All the choir of heaven and furniture of earth – in a word, all those bodies which compose the frame of the world – have not any subsistence without a mind.”

Advertisement

The self-regarding mind of Mr Trump could be said to mirror this. Last week, a New York Times reporter caught him in a Berkeleyan mindset, as it were. The interview covered tout le monde, even though its ­duration was but a half-hour.

Zhongnanhai carefully noted that the “reality show” inside the president’s mind did not exclude China, nor its president, Xi Jinping.

President Donald Trump: from brash to blunt

Advertisement
Select Voice
Select Speed
1.00x