-
Advertisement
US-China trade war
Opinion
Tom Plate

Opinion | In the US-China trade war, where is the bilateral humanity and the listening ear?

Tom Plate says a three-dimensional view of China rather than stereotypical and simplistic thinking is needed to break the current impasse in US-China relations

Reading Time:4 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Illustration: Craig Stephens
A China of 1.4 billion people cannot possibly be sewn up into one massive blanket of monochromatic metaphor. And if the Communist Party (membership: 89 million, all by itself) does efficiently enlist so many of the country’s brightest, how can all these ambitious Communist Party minds possibly agree on everything?

Beneath the comforting cover of the imagined totalitarian China blanket, a surface which is often all the West sees, one can detect not only an interior yin and yang – not to mention the occasional foreign-relations ping and pong – but a measure of ongoing “conversations” over this and that, if only we would just listen and read between the lines. 

New reports highlight that Xi Jinping, China’s president and party chief, is narrowing the parameters of permissible debate, that the mainland media is feeling more fenced in than usual, and that professors are being pressured to toe the party line.
Advertisement
A law professor from the famed Tsinghua University, Xi’s alma mater, fears that his beloved China is heading back to the future, one with intellectually closed ranks and mandated Communist catechisms. Last but not least, out in China’s West, a sort of Rohingya-comparable detention and purge campaign looks to be playing out against Muslim Uygurs.
For the first time, doubts about Xi, the term-limitless president, are starting to crawl out from under the party floorboards. On the one hand, it is said, Xi enjoys too much control. Pessimists – or alarmists – now claim to see, rising from the historical miasma of mainland politics, the ghoulish outlines of the ghost of Mao Zedong, though it must be noted this would hardly be the first such post-Deng Xiaoping “sighting”.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x