Advertisement
OpinionLetters

Only way to conserve Lugard Road property is to keep it as residence

I agree with the letter by J. Lee Rofkind ("Conversion to hotel will not save mansion", July 26).

Reading Time:2 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
The historic mansion at 27 Lugard Road. Photo: K. Y. Cheng
Letters
I agree with the letter by J. Lee Rofkind ("Conversion to hotel will not save mansion", July 26). She was responding to the comments made by Dr Lee Ho-yin on the proposed hotel development at 27 Lugard Road on The Peak ("Take a Peak into the past...",July 10).

I am one of those who opposes the hotel development, and I lived at 27 Lugard Road for over 12 years. Based on my knowledge and experience of the property and its neighbourhood, am I, according to Dr Lee, "completely wrong, misguided and misinformed"?

I fail to see how gutting a perfect interior and subdividing it into 13 small rooms can be regarded as "conservation". Conservation goes beyond just preserving bricks and mortar.

Advertisement

Lugard Road itself is a heritage site, and No27 is part of this heritage. Anyone genuinely concerned about conservation would keep the house as it is, as a family residence.

It has been fastidiously maintained over the years and is in perfect condition. There is no valid reason to demolish or disfigure it.

Advertisement

I have driven in and out of Lugard Road close to 10,000 times over the years and am more qualified than Dr Lee on traffic issues. With ever increasing human traffic, it has become too hazardous to drive along there.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x