Advertisement
Education
OpinionLetters

Can Hong Kong read the signs on the best ways to empower the hearing-impaired?

Reading Time:2 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
A hearing-impaired baby attends a bilingual (sign language and spoken language) programme at a Hong Kong Society for the Protection of Children creche, in Mong Kok in 2014. Photo: Edward Wong
Letters
I am writing in response to the article on a school for the deaf in Beijing taking part in a campaign to standardise Chinese sign language, starting the new school term with the official sign language version for the national anthem (“Please be upstanding for China’s sign language national anthem”, September 3).

Medical and technological advances have made it possible for hearing aids and cochlear implants to boost both the listening and speaking skills of those with hearing impairments, and these are always advocated as aids. However, the deaf still struggle to keep up with the majority, the hearing-enabled individuals.

Is fitting the hearing-impaired into conventional living patterns really the best way to help them? Does this really allow them to recognise their own identity and cultivate their own ways of effortless communication?

Advertisement

In reality, for the sake of getting a decent job and earning enough to support themselves, the deaf find themselves confronting the dominant norms on how to speak and read. Despite encountering difficulties with lip-reading and mouth-shape mimicry, they struggle harder to learn how to speak a proper language to justify their value and usefulness to society.

We certainly need to end the mainstream hegemonic practice of oralism when it comes to language planning. Sign language should no longer be an afterthought but be promoted in schools. Indeed, many overseas studies illustrate that the spoken language among deaf children will not be hindered by learning sign language. Instead, early sign language training brings benefits like better knowledge of vocabulary, reinforcement of speech development and enhanced cognitive skills.

Advertisement
Students at the Beijing Qiyin Experimental School in Beijing practise the national anthem in sign language. Photo: Iqiyi.com
Students at the Beijing Qiyin Experimental School in Beijing practise the national anthem in sign language. Photo: Iqiyi.com
Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x