Why Victor Mallet does not have widespread support in Hong Kong despite outrage in the West
PUBLISHED : Wednesday, 17 October, 2018, 4:15am
UPDATED : Wednesday, 17 October, 2018, 4:15am
Related topics
The Hong Kong Immigration Department’s decision not to renew the visa of the Financial Times’ Asia news editor Victor Mallet is neither “chilling” nor “deeply troubling”. Mr Mallet chose to host an event that confronted the sovereignty of China, not in his capacity as a journalist but as first vice-president of the Foreign Correspondents’ Club; he was not reporting news, he was creating it.
Mr Mallet chose to ignore government requests to cancel a talk by Andy Chan Ho-tin, leader of the now banned Hong Kong National Party, and instead provided a platform for an extremist. The talk also ignited division in Hong Kong, including protests by people who objected to the FCC’s hosting of the event. Judging by comments from readers and others in your newspaper, many do not support Mr Mallet.
Freedom of speech is not an invitation to challenge the sovereignty of a nation, nor is it a right to create division by offering a platform for political subversion. The West seems intent on painting Hong Kong as a city suffering under Chinese interference, but the truth is rather different. A poll of people in the street in Hong Kong would find many condemning Mr Mallet, Mr Chan and others who seek to undermine our city’s place within China.
Mark Peaker, The Peak
Watch: Hong Kong leader Carrie Lam responds to denial of visa for Victor Mallet
Britain’s ‘hostile’ immigration policy trumps Hong Kong’s silliness
Philip Dyke’s remarks on the silliness of Hong Kong’s visa decision are misleading, to say the least (“Journalist’s visa refusal made Hong Kong ‘look silly’”, October 16). Has he taken the time to research Britain’s “hostile environment policy” on immigration? Theresa May’s immigration policy has, among other things, divided thousands of families in which a spouse is a non-European.
And no, it isn’t just a matter of people being unable to fulfil financial criteria. It’s mostly about ambiguity, high costs of getting visas and the Home Office’s blatant incompetence.
Justin Hayward, Tai Po
Most Popular
Viewed
- 1
![Recently, reports surfaced that the Housing Authority had imposed a restriction on late-night cooking in Wo Lok Estate in Kwun Tong. Residents were instructed to refrain from “making meat-chopping, vegetable-cutting, stir-frying and chiselling noises”, so not as to disturb neighbours. Photo: Jonathan Wong]( "Recently, reports surfaced that the Housing Authority had imposed a restriction on late-night cooking in Wo Lok Estate in Kwun Tong. Residents were instructed to refrain from “making meat-chopping, vegetable-cutting, stir-frying and chiselling noises”, so not as to disturb neighbours. Photo: Jonathan Wong")
- 2
![Louis Cha, who wrote under the name Jin Yong, was eager to have his stories gain recognition globally, the author’s former English translator writes. Photo: Reuters]( "Louis Cha, who wrote under the name Jin Yong, was eager to have his stories gain recognition globally, the author’s former English translator writes. Photo: Reuters")
- 3
![Illustration: Craig Stephens]( "Illustration: Craig Stephens")
- 4
![Australian Prime Minister Scott Morrison. Photo: EPA]( "Australian Prime Minister Scott Morrison. Photo: EPA")
- 5
![Illustration: Craig Stephens]( "Illustration: Craig Stephens")
Shared
- 1
![Louis Cha, who wrote under the name Jin Yong, was eager to have his stories gain recognition globally, the author’s former English translator writes. Photo: Reuters]( "Louis Cha, who wrote under the name Jin Yong, was eager to have his stories gain recognition globally, the author’s former English translator writes. Photo: Reuters")
- 2
![Recently, reports surfaced that the Housing Authority had imposed a restriction on late-night cooking in Wo Lok Estate in Kwun Tong. Residents were instructed to refrain from “making meat-chopping, vegetable-cutting, stir-frying and chiselling noises”, so not as to disturb neighbours. Photo: Jonathan Wong]( "Recently, reports surfaced that the Housing Authority had imposed a restriction on late-night cooking in Wo Lok Estate in Kwun Tong. Residents were instructed to refrain from “making meat-chopping, vegetable-cutting, stir-frying and chiselling noises”, so not as to disturb neighbours. Photo: Jonathan Wong")
- 3
![Illustration: Craig Stephens]( "Illustration: Craig Stephens")
- 4
![Illustration: Craig Stephens]( "Illustration: Craig Stephens")
- 5
![Illustration: Craig Stephens]( "Illustration: Craig Stephens")
Commented
- 1
![The entrance to Petaling Street in Kuala Lumpur’s Chinatown, in Malaysia. Picture: Alamy]( "The entrance to Petaling Street in Kuala Lumpur’s Chinatown, in Malaysia. Picture: Alamy")
- 2
![Would you drink hot water on a scorching summer’s day? Many Hongkongers do]()
- 3
![Tran Qui Thanh and daughter Phuong Uyen Tran at their Tan Hiep Phat Beverage Group factory in Vietnam. Photo: Tan Hiep Phat Beverage Group]( "Tran Qui Thanh and daughter Phuong Uyen Tran at their Tan Hiep Phat Beverage Group factory in Vietnam. Photo: Tan Hiep Phat Beverage Group")
- 4
![For many overworked people, the office may be the only place they can find love. But office romances have the potential to ruin careers
Beware romances where one person has professional authority over another]( "For many overworked people, the office may be the only place they can find love. But office romances have the potential to ruin careers
Beware romances where one person has professional authority over another")
- 5
![English proficiency: an Asian nation in top three for first time in survey of non-native speakers]()
You may also like
To filter or not to filter? Hi-tech devices tap into clean water debate
In partnership with: HKT PREMIER
Qeelin dares you to wear denim jewellery
Brought to you by: Qeelin
Comments: