-
Advertisement
Singapore
OpinionLetters

Letters | Singapore risks seeing worthy local research sidelined in hurry to climb up global university rankings

  • The publicly funded Presidential Young Professor scheme, with its high salaries and big research grants, exacts a large opportunity cost for non-PYP faculty

Reading Time:2 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
The National University of Singapore. Research is the lifeblood of academia, so there must be a secure place in Singapore’s universities for local tenure-track faculty and others doing local research that may not be published in highly ranked international journals or contribute to global university rankings. Photo: Shutterstock
Letters
Professor Danny Quah’s December 16 response to our commentary on the National University of Singapore’s (NUS) Presidential Young Professor (PYP) scheme is full of straw men. It avoids engaging with our argument that the scheme involves a huge commitment of public financial resources that is globally unprecedented in non-STEM fields, and unsustainable in STEM fields.

It exacts a large opportunity cost in reduced resources for non-PYP faculty (the money must come from somewhere), exacerbates inequities and divisions among faculty of different ranks (PYP, non-PYP tenure-track, educator), and generates uncertainty and insecurity over faculty hiring and promotion standards.

All of these diminish morale and impede faculty recruitment and retention, undermining collaborative research and undergraduate teaching.

Advertisement

Prof Quah does not dispute that the recent roll-out of non-STEM PYP has been accompanied by administration rejection of job candidates selected by departments for tenure-track faculty positions, and of departments’ and external reviewers’ recommendations to tenure existing faculty, who previously would have been accepted.

Technicians work on programming a 3D printer at the Nanyang Technological University (NTU) in Singapore in 2017. The National University of Singapore has launched a scheme that offers a high salary and generous research funding to attract research talent not only in the STEM fields but also non-STEM fields such as the humanities. Photo: Reuters
Technicians work on programming a 3D printer at the Nanyang Technological University (NTU) in Singapore in 2017. The National University of Singapore has launched a scheme that offers a high salary and generous research funding to attract research talent not only in the STEM fields but also non-STEM fields such as the humanities. Photo: Reuters
Advertisement

Overseas Graduate Scholarship and Overseas Postdoctoral Fellowship recipients have told us that some returnees have been unexpectedly placed on the educator track, which is “a career dead-end for Singaporean PhDs”, given the “higher teaching load and little research support”.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x