-
Advertisement
Transport and logistics
OpinionLetters

Letters | Four more years of crawling through tunnels: why Hong Kong must grin and bear it

  • The government’s withdrawal of the proposal to rationalise cross-harbour tunnel tolls in the face of legislator opposition only kicks the problem down the road

Reading Time:2 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
The government’s proposal to raise toll fees at two of Hong Kong’s three harbour crossings, including the heavily used Cross-Harbour Tunnel, while lowering them at the third would have effectively evened out traffic. Photo: Xiaomei Chen
Letters
I am very disappointed at the Hong Kong government’s recent withdrawal of the proposal to rationalise cross-harbour tunnel tolls from the Legislative Council. I am disappointed with the legislators’ objection to it, which apparently stemmed from their fear of becoming unpopular with their electorate if they supported the proposal to substantially raise fees at two of the tunnels.

The proposal, which aimed to even out traffic flow among the three cross-harbour tunnels and therefore ease congestion, was long overdue. It is a real attempt to relieve jams at the Cross-Harbour Tunnel, which currently charges a ridiculously low toll fee of HK$20 for private cars. This is the cheapest, arguably shortest and most heavily used of the cross-harbour tunnels, despite the fact that the Eastern Harbour Tunnel charges only HK$5 more at HK$25.

The proposed increase to HK$40 is a huge jump percentage-wise; however, in terms of the time gained back when congestion is eased, it is very good value for money.

Advertisement
The overall package includes, inter alia, a plan to waive toll charges for franchised buses using government tunnels and roads, thereby easing the pressure for a fare hike on public transport. It is not a bad proposal, warranting serious consideration and debate.
Advertisement

If both parties (the government and the legislators) are genuinely concerned about addressing the congestion problems which have haunted the city for decades, they should discuss the issue and negotiate for a compromise.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x