Advertisement
Hong Kong extradition bill
OpinionLetters

Letters | How Hong Kong can make a name for itself with amended extradition law

  • By trying Hongkongers for crimes committed abroad, then allowing other countries to apply for extradition, Hong Kong can maintain its reputation

Reading Time:2 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Supporters of the Hong Kong government’s move to amend the fugitive transfers law and widen extradition arrangements, demonstrate in Wan Chai on June 1. Photo: Winson Wong
Letters

Regarding extradition, I first staffed this matter when working for the police in Hong Kong in 1995; it appeared to me at the time to be an acute problem and I am amazed that 24 years have now passed and the issue still remains.

There is no doubt that this matter must be addressed, and Hong Kong’s reputation will only suffer if we harbour our citizens who should face hearings/trials in other jurisdictions. I believe we should pass legislation allowing Hong Kong residents to apply to be tried in Hong Kong for crimes committed abroad. Foreign jurisdictions could apply to have them apprehended and be remanded on bail or otherwise for serious offences, while they put their case together.

A proper facility should be built here to assist foreign jurisdictions to properly present their cases, including low-charge housing for witnesses when testimony cannot be taken by video link.

Upon being convicted, the person would be sentenced in Hong Kong and carry out their sentences here. A suspect would also be told that, even if they were dealt with here, the foreign jurisdiction could still take action against them in the future if they were to leave Hong Kong. Foreign visitors who seek haven in Hong Kong would merely be told to leave or be deported at the end of their visa term.

Advertisement

A robust and fair legal system is a must for Hong Kong to maintain its reputation and to remain one of the most important cities in Southeast Asia.

Jeff Herbert, Kai Kuk Shue Ha

Advertisement
Chief Executive Carrie Lam leaves a meeting at the Legislative Council on May 22. Pro-democracy lawmakers have expressed their concerns about the new controversial law that would allow the extradition of suspected criminals to jurisdictions including mainland China. Photo: AP
Chief Executive Carrie Lam leaves a meeting at the Legislative Council on May 22. Pro-democracy lawmakers have expressed their concerns about the new controversial law that would allow the extradition of suspected criminals to jurisdictions including mainland China. Photo: AP
Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x