-
Advertisement
Education
OpinionLetters

Letters | Hong Kong paying the price for an education system that doesn’t teach youth how to agree to disagree

  • Differences of opinion are inevitable, but our schools aren’t teaching young people how to express their divergent views in a productive way

Reading Time:2 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
The defaced national emblem at Beijing’s liaison office in Sai Ying Pun after some protesters temporarily lay siege to it following a mass rally on July 21. Photo: Kyodo
Letters

The recent protests in Hong Kong reflect an epic deficit in our education system: the lack of emphasis on teaching respectful communication.

This does not come as a surprise, since our education system has long focused on memorisation and written proficiency, with little emphasis on communication. For example, during Diploma of Secondary Education (DSE) group discussions or university entry interviews, which are supposed to be a test of oral proficiency, what students say is often scripted and unauthentic: “I agree with your point, but ….”

In class, I try very hard to encourage students to speak up about what they think. With a few exceptions, almost all Hong Kong students make no attempt whatsoever to communicate. They sit at the back of the lecture hall, stare at their computer screen, and don’t say a word. How do we expect them to articulate their views clearly and respectfully in society when they seldom do so in the classroom?

Advertisement
The effects of poor training for communication in our education system extend beyond university. In organisations, a lack of dialogue between higher-ups and front-line employees is common. The power dynamic is such that the boss is always right and followers have little opportunity to present challenging yet potentially good ideas.
The ivory tower is everywhere, and when things go pear-shaped, there is the inevitable breakdown in communication that is too late or too impossible to resolve, which is what we are observing in Hong Kong right now (“Tear gas and rubber bullets fired as central Hong Kong becomes war zone”, July 21).
Advertisement
Advertisement
Select Voice
Select Speed
1.00x