-
Advertisement
Hong Kong protests
OpinionLetters

Letters | Hong Kong police in riots city: scared boys with lethal toys need better leaders

  • In 1967, officers faced down aggressive rioters with little save their discipline and resolve. Fast-forward to 2019, and over-armed officers facing less dangerous protesters are clearly in need of leadership

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
A line of police officers in Lan Kwai Fong, Hong Kong’s entertainment district, during Halloween night on October 31. Photo: AFP
Letters

Fifty-two and a half years ago, my troop of Royal Marines and I had our anti-riot drill honed by the mostly unarmed and unarmoured, but extremely impressive, smart, disciplined and crisply authoritative personnel of the Hong Kong police.

Happily, we were never called on to use what we had learned. But we saw and, later, admiringly watched news coverage of how Hong Kong police faced down extremely aggressive rioters with little save their discipline, smartness, courage and resolve.
How sad today to see an over-armed, over-protected and, in too many cases, unquestionably thuggish semi-rabble, facing with such apparent indiscipline protesters no better armed, nor more malevolent than in 1967.
Advertisement

The poorly led rank and file of today’s police force, overreliant on technology instead of disciplined authority, have too often run amok. Scared boys with lethal toys need better leaders than it seems the force now has. The results of these failings have brought the force into disrepute and caused a rift between society and police that might take a generation or more to mend.

That this same force seems incapable of admitting some of its officers have broken the law and should be brought to justice is a disgrace. It is far worse that a senior officer should be so far distanced from properly lawful conduct that when an officer fires a potentially fatal shot, he pronounces that action entirely justified with no respect for due process.

Worst is the supine non-leadership at the top of the Hong Kong government that not merely allows such conduct by police, but appears to condone it.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Select Speed
1.00x