Advertisement
Letters | Throughout the protests, Hong Kong’s government, universities and police have been reasonable
- The anti-mask law was rooted in a policing need and the police force has provided explanations for its more controversial actions
- While universities have allowed students to express their opinions, to protect politically neutral students, activism has no place on campuses
Reading Time:2 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
I am writing to respond to Adrian Lam’s letter “If students want the truth on police action, so must the keepers of the law” (November 1).
Advertisement
I disagree with Mr Lam that the government instituting an anti-mask law was an unwise move. As many radical protesters wear black masks which fully cover their faces, it is difficult for the police to identify who attacked them or engaged in illegal actions. Although the law may be unpopular, it can help the police arrest miscreants more easily.
Moreover, people who have health issues or need to cover their faces for religious reasons are exempted from the law. So the law is quite fair.
Secondly, Mr Lam said universities must offer an independent and a free environment for students to seek knowledge and truth. In fact, universities did hold activities to let the students express their thoughts, such as dialogues between university heads and students. But the students used disrespectful and ridiculous ways to express their emotions. They have exceeded the freedom that the universities have given them.
I support education institutions banning activism on their premises to ensure a safe environment for the students who are politically neutral and simply want to focus on their studies.
Thirdly, I don’t agree with Mr Lam that the government must seek the truth by establishing an independent commission to look into allegations of police excesses. In other countries, such as Iran, the police have fired live rounds on protesters. The Hong Kong police have rarely done this and when they did, they provided an explanation.
Advertisement
Advertisement