Advertisement
Advertisement
Coronavirus pandemic: All stories
Get more with myNEWS
A personalised news feed of stories that matter to you
Learn more
Passengers of the Diamond Princess send off those leaving the cruise terminal in Yokohama, Japan, on February 19, after a two-week quarantine period following a coronavirus outbreak. Photo: EPA-EFE

Letters | Coronavirus bullies: Diamond Princess ‘patient zero’ a classic case of victim-blaming

My heart broke to read the report, “Coronavirus: Hong Kong resident denies he is ‘patient zero’ of Diamond Princess cruise ship outbreak” (March 12), featuring the 80-year-old Mr Wu, labelled as “patient zero” on the Diamond Princess and dubbed the “King of Virus” by internet users.
Not long ago, local and international news outlets were avidly reporting the number of confirmed cases on the cruise ship 24/7: “44 more cases on Diamond Princess cruise ship anchored off Japan”, “99 more cases on Diamond Princess as US evacuates citizens”, “British man who was on Diamond Princess dies in Japan”.

We read such reports throughout February and worried about those on the ship. Unfortunately, more than 700 people got infected and seven lost their lives.

Imagine how Mr Wu, with all those epithets attached to his name, was made to feel. It was sad to read about how he calculated and investigated whether he was really “patient zero”. It is clear that the label – which tacitly holds him liable for the loss of at least seven lives – affected him deeply.

“Patient zero” or not, the fact is that Mr Wu is also a victim of Covid-19; he too contracted the virus from someone else and his life was also at risk. More importantly, Mr Wu did not board the ship with significant Covid-19 symptoms.

It is unfair for him to be bullied and blamed for contracting an infectious disease: this is victim-blaming.

Tiffany Choi, Fanling

Stop using Covid-19 to make scapegoats of Asians

I would like to commend Ms Karen Zhang on her report on the so-called patient zero on the Diamond Princess, “Hongkonger denies he is cruise ship’s ‘patient zero’” (March 12).

Ever since Covid-19 began to spread across the world, Chinese and other Asians have come to be ridiculed and abused by ignorant Westerners under the influence of biased information. So far, it has not been conclusively proven that the virus even originated in the Chinese city of Wuhan.

The interview with the patient should be widely publicised to clear his name. This is an opportunity to let Westerners know it is extremely unfair to treat Chinese or Asians as the scapegoats amid this pandemic.

Also, it is about time the Hong Kong government stepped up its public relations strategy.

Tina Niem, Repulse Bay

No surprise that China rushed to Italy’s aid

As the novel coronavirus causing the potentially deadly Covid-19 sweeps the globe, Italy is now struggling to contain the spread of the disease, becoming the second most affected country after China (“Italy hits single-day record with 250 new coronavirus deaths”, March 14). To date, Italy has recorded more than 31,500 confirmed cases and over 2,500 deaths.
Naturally, Italy would have asked the European Union for help when faced with a public health crisis of this magnitude. However, the country seems to have been abandoned by the EU.
Instead, it was China that came to Italy’s aid. A nine-member medical team flew over 7,500km with 30 tonnes of medical supplies, including masks and respirators, arriving in Rome on March 12.
In fact, it is not surprising that China extended help. In the 1970s, China and Western countries had complicated political relationships. But long before becoming an EU member, Italy had established good diplomatic relations with China. The Italian government recognised the People’s Republic of China in November 1970, nearly five years before the European Community opened diplomatic relations with Beijing.

In the 1980s, Italy helped Sichuan province set up its largest medical emergency centre, and doctors from Chongqing received emergency medical training in Italy. This was long before China became an economic powerhouse and was a big helping hand from Italy. Then in 2008, Italian emergency workers helped to rescue hundreds of trapped survivors after the devastating May 12 earthquake. At least five members of the Chinese medical team that went to Italy last week are from Sichuan.

Randy Lee, Ma On Shan

Post