-
Advertisement
Hong Kong protests
OpinionLetters

Letters | Why the media owe Hong Kong’s arrested young protesters an apology

  • The media helped to create a climate that allowed young rioters to feel like warriors for justice, leaving many of them with nothing but a criminal record and regret

Reading Time:2 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Hong Kong protesters set up roadblocks on Argyle Street in Mong Kok during anti-government demonstrations in November. Photo: Sam Tsang
Letters
The Hong Kong anti-extradition bill campaign ended up damaging and dividing the city. We have seen the arrest of veteran political figures and youngsters, the withdrawal of the extradition bill but the imposition of the national security law. Maybe the city’s wounds can heal. Debate will continue over whether Hong Kong’s political figures should have been better prepared to handle matters on their own. The national security law may target just a few – or even no one, eventually. But youngsters found guilty will possess a criminal record which will curb their prospects. Who should feel guilty about this?

People in Hong Kong by and large trusted the media to report on happenings in the city during the anti-extradition protests. Unfortunately, to a large extent, the context, photos and footage steered readers towards a particular end, intentionally or otherwise.

The news mostly showed the police using vengeful force to subdue the protesters, the pan-democrat figures rationalising the rioters’ aggressive actions in all spheres, and a need for the government to accept the rioters’ enthusiastic demands. Alas, the rioters have been represented as “justice warriors”.
Advertisement

This could be seen as a call for civic awakening among Hongkongers, sending out the message that the “justice warriors” were vulnerable and looking for help. Young readers are the most susceptible. Glorification of protests could see them steered and inspired to participate in the street riots.

On the ground, almost all journalists were seen standing in front of the rioters to capture police actions – effectively barricading the officers. That has led to suggestions that journalists have taken sides, supporting the rioters, and so the young participants in the riots would never feel alone.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x